In politics, it’s a problem when the opposition to a bill can’t clearly explain why they are opposed. It’s doubly so when the issue is of critical importance to voters.
That’s the circumstance facing Gov. Phil Scott and the Legislature’s Republicans.
One of the most important issues facing Vermont is the cost of health care, something Vermonters face every day with almost every bill and every purchase. In the final week of the session, the Legislature did something about it. A bill was passed that would speed up the implementation of what’s called “reference-based” pricing, which means tying private insurance payout rates to Medicare benchmarks.
It’s the only bill passed by the Legislature to deal with Vermont’s “highest in the nation” health care premiums. Yet, it was opposed by almost all Republicans, and reports suggest Mr. Scott may veto the bill. Why? State Senator Russ Ingalls [R-Essex] said Republicans were opposed to a bill that would “transform” our current health care system without knowing exactly how much would be saved.
So the answer is to do nothing?
That’s allowing perfection to be the enemy of good. Vermont is already slated to move to a “reference-based” pricing system in 2028. What the Legislature’s bill does is speed up that process by a year, and apply the pricing procedure to Vermonters who buy their insurance through Vermont Health Connect, and to those who are employees of the state’s public school system. Two key groups.
A central purpose is to allow the Green Mountain Care Board, the state’s healthcare regulator, to more clearly define how the reference-based pricing policy could work in a more controlled environment. In other words, not only would the bill address two key groups, helping reduce costs, but it would also aid in the state’s move to the reference-based pricing plan in 2028. The thought is that the more experience with the new pricing system, the better.
Owen Foster, chair of the Green Mountain Care Board, is a supporter of S. 190, noting that if state employee and teacher health plan payments had been tied to 200 percent of Medicare’s charges from 2018 to 2023, the state would have saved roughly $400 million. In other words, there are some real savings in the pricing plan.
Mr. Foster is also mindful of the need to protect our hospitals’ fiscal integrity, but the Vermont Hospital Association has maintained a “neutral” stance on the bill and has acknowledged that Vermont’s hospitals could absorb $50 million in reduced annual revenue over the next two years without putting themselves at risk or reducing patient services.
For most Vermonters, the bottom line is about cost. On the affordability front, health insurance premiums have risen about three times faster than worker earnings since 1999. Those costs are reflected in people’s everyday lives, everything from property taxes to the costs of goods and services, to college tuition, and on and on.
If our hospitals are neutral on the bill, and if it has the support of the Green Mountain Care Board, and if it speeds up the lowering of costs to public school employees and those who buy insurance on the state’s health care exchange, and if Vermonters start to feel the benefit of reduced health care premiums sooner rather than later, then why would the Republicans and the governor oppose it?
It’s a challenge that begs our attention. S.190 is a welcome step forward toward a more affordable health care system. Opposing it makes no sense. This is something the governor should embrace, and his Republican tribe should follow.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here