When Vermont enacted the Global Warming Solutions Act in 2020 it included a provision that allowed practically anyone to sue the state if they believed the state was not on track to meet the law’s benchmarks. The law also stipulates that the legal costs of such lawsuits would be borne by the taxpayer.
On Tuesday, the Conservation Law Foundation [CLF] notified the state it would exercise that privilege. It is suing the Vermont Agency of Natural Resources [VNR] contending the state is using a modeling system that has produced figures that do not match the figures used by CLF’s modeling experts.
Julie Moore, VNR’s secretary, claims otherwise, saying their modeling numbers have been investigated and that the agency “remained confident with the analysis that had been conducted.”
The lawsuit is no surprise. It was anticipated the moment the bill passed the legislature and was one of the reasons Gov. Phil Scott vetoed the bill. It puts the state in the awkward position of having to change policies on the fly with little reflection as to cost or effectiveness.
This was confirmed by CLF’s legal notice which made the point that if the state is not on track to meet its first goal in 2025 that “pursuant to statute” the law “should prompt the swift adoption of one or more new rules and/or amendment of one or more existing rules.”
Whose rules? Which ones, exactly? At what cost?
CLF’s lawsuit, although not unexpected, is seemingly trivial which should make any observer wary. If the dispute between CLF and the state is just about who does the modeling, then the state has the option of picking another group to do the same analysis. Of all of the act’s challenges, finding common ground on which modeling expert to follow may be one of the easier ones to resolve. But what’s next?
No one knows, which illustrates the need for the Legislature to reassess its position. Four years have passed since the law was enacted and by next January we are supposed to have reduced our emissions by 26 percent below 2005 levels. That number skyrockets to a 40 percent reduction below 1990 emission levels by 2030 and 80 percent below 1990 emission levels by 2050.
The Legislature should reconsider just how willing Vermonters should be to have CLF guide our emission policy and at what cost. It should be obvious that there is no downside to CLF’s decision to sue and they will continue to do so. It costs them nothing since Vermont’s taxpayers are picking up the tab and they use such suits to raise money from their donors. For them, being in court is a win-win.
The Legislature - now four years into the law’s requirements - should redraft the legislation, recognizing that expensive lawsuits do nothing but spend the taxpayers’s dollars unnecessarily and delay the more important work of actually reducing emissions. We also need a clearer idea of what meeting the emission targets will cost, and how those costs will be met. Few of us, if any, know the answer. Transparency does not now exist. That needs to be changed.
The Global Warming Solutions Act was passed in the midst of the Covid epidemic. The world was turned upside down and today’s reality is much different than in 2020. Not only are we dealing with the effects of reduced federal funding, we’re faced with enormous financial challenges in our health care and educational systems and with our lack of housing. As legislators know, or should, at some point taxpayers will scream enough, ushering in those to office who practice fiscal prudence. If we are not there now, we soon will be.
CLF’s lawsuit is a warning to legislators that they are placing environmental progress at risk by spending money and time in a courtroom. The law needs to be rewritten to that effect and taxpayers need to be told what’s ahead and at what cost; they are growing weary of being the bug squished on the windshield of a Legislature that values speed more than direction.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here