The Oliver-Wyman report issued six months ago warned of a dire future for Vermont’s hospitals if current practices were not changed. The report - paid for by the Legislature and overseen by the Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB] - made it clear that while none of its recommendations were mandated doing nothing was not an option if the state’s health care system was to survive, let alone prosper.
The report’s recommendations were advisory, not prescriptive. It was intended to sound the alarm and provide the information others would need to respond.
That response is starting to show itself. Last Friday the Legislature’s two health care committees offered near unanimous support for bills that would address not only the financial well-being of the state’s health care system writ large, but the affordability and availability of healthcare to Vermonters.
It’s an undertaking as daunting as the governor’s proposal to redraw what the state’s educational system looks like. And as important. The healthcare system in Vermont constitutes 20 percent of the state’s gross domestic project and touches almost every person in the state. Getting it right is paramount.
This is not an exercise to make something better that’s already good. It’s a mission to bring stability to something in danger of collapse. Both bills focus this obligation on the shoulders of the GMCB, the state’s healthcare regulator. If passed by the Legislature and signed into law by the governor, it will be the most significant expansion of the board’s power since it was established in 2011.
Expanding the reach of a government regulatory authority isn’t typically what we’d recommend, but, given the challenges facing our healthcare community, it’s difficult to see a workable alternative. The testimony offered last week by Owen Foster, chair of the GMCB, was nothing short of frightening. In 2024 we had six of our hospitals losing money and Gifford Hospital in Randolph lost a whopping $10 million. BlueCross BlueShield - one of the state’s two insurers - lost $62 million. Mr. Foster made it clear the trend line was not sustainable, nor is our healthcare system capable of resolving its challenges by itself.
Hence, the legislation would vastly increase the power of the GMCB to not only support the hospitals that need support, but to push them to change their payment systems, move toward global budgets, and reach into a hospital’s operations to cut costs. As Sen. Ginny Lyons, D-Chittenden Southeast, and chair of the Senate Committee on Health and Welfare was quoted as saying: “The most important thing is we’re trying to get out of the health care crisis that we’re in.”
Ms. Lyons is correct in pushing the issue to the forefront. It’s not a crisis that can be managed without the state’s regulator being given more power than it has. The proposed legislation, for example, pushes the GMCB to implement reference-based pricing, which means that the prices charged by hospitals to private insurance companies would be matched to Medicare rates. The bill would also have the state’s healthcare system develop a “statewide healthcare delivery plan” which would not only coordinate statewide care priorities but would bring efficiency to the system.
These are not objectives that can be accomplished hospital by hospital. And it’s not something the University of Vermont Medical Center and the University of Vermont Health Network - which controls about two-thirds of the state’s hospital market - sees in its best interests. That makes leadership among the state’s hospitals a challenging if not impossible task. There is no coordinating force to bring the state’s hospitals together with a single voice for a common purpose. It's a crisis beyond their will and ability to solve.
Meanwhile, the self-interest that comes with separation has left us with a patchwork healthcare system that is costly and coming apart.
There will be changes to the bills as they proceed through the legislative process. But, between Mr. Foster’s testimony and the testimony of others familiar with the crisis that threatens our healthcare system, it’s encouraging to see legislators stepping up to the challenge.
Vermonters pay the highest health care premiums in the nation. That’s not sustainable. Vermont has its largest insurer on the verge of bankruptcy. That’s not an option for Vermonters who need the coverage. We have parts of the state whose demographics make it difficult to keep hospitals afloat. We need the leadership to present sustainable options.
The legislation being considered is a beginning. We trust the governor’s office is aware of the legislation and supports its direction.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here