Legislature makes progress, more to do

Posted

If the November election hadn’t decimated the Democratic ranks Vermont’s legislators would have been home in mid-May, they would not be debating a generational change in the state’s educational and most likely would not have passed legislation dealing with the cost of health care, or a major bill to help amp up housing development, particularly in rural Vermont.

That’s the power of politics. Gov. Scott’s non-stop insistence that Vermont had an affordability issue finally broke through in a way that cost many Democrats their jobs. They didn’t heed the anger of voters who were furious with a 14 percent increase in their property tax bills.

To the Democrats' leadership’s credit, they told their troops that could not happen again and pushed them back toward the political middle where most Vermonters reside.

Hence, the legislative session can be fairly described as productive, and on a notable scale. Think about it: there were three key challenges before the Legislature [and Vermont.] There was a change in how we structure the state’s educational system [something that affects every town in the state]. There was the issue of a collapsing healthcare system. And there was the looming crisis of a housing market that we talked about but did nothing to make a difference.

On each issue, the newly cast Legislature took a step forward. Each of the three carried the governor’s message of affordability. The Democrats, thankfully, found it preferable to share some of the governor's goodwill on matters of the purse. 

Fingers crossed. This could be one of those pivotal moments when bipartisanship prevails and parties on both sides decide the voters would prefer progress to partisanship. [We said fingers crossed.]

The issue that threatens the comity is, obviously, the education bill. There is something for everyone to dislike. And the areas that will like it least are those who fear losing their schools, due to requirements that impose minimum class sizes. There will be opposition to a new foundation formula for school funding. There will be those opposed to Montpelier deciding school funding levels, not local voters. There will be those opposed to a change in governance structure, dramatically reducing the number of supervisory unions. There will be questions about how to handle teacher contacts when the lines are redrawn on supervisory unions.

There is hardly anything in the education bill that is certain. In fact, there are more off-ramps than on-ramps. If, for example, legislators are not able to agree on what the new supervisory unions will look like, then nothing happens. Legislators were careful to give themselves the necessary flexibility to adjust to any circumstance, but still, it’s a heavy, heavy lift and one that will consume the next legislative session, which is also an election year.

The difference between this year’s debate and those in the past is one of urgency, of reaching that point of no return. The argument has been made and agreed to: what we have is not sustainable for the taxpayer, nor is it producing acceptable outcomes for our students. To do nothing obligates us to a future of higher costs and worsening outcomes. 

What’s most essential is to confine the debate to issues that have a meaningful outcome. The foundation formula, for example, has to be set up in a way that keeps downward pressure on costs. We need far fewer supervisory unions than we have now, but the new configuration has to be efficient and reflective of the districts being supervised. And, as difficult as it will be, it’s crucial that any legislation include minimum class sizes. It’s all for naught if it isn’t included.

That said, those opposed to the bill because voters will no longer be required to approve or disapprove of their school’s local school budget are off base. There are only a handful of states that have their voters vote on school budgets. In the vast majority of states, people express their concerns about school spending by electing people on the school board who reflect their views. The claim that we would be moving away from a “democratic system” to one that’s not is a red herring.

In sum, we got to first base this legislative session. That’s an achievement. It will require the same level of attention next session as this session if we are to succeed. 

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here