When Gov. Phil Scott said he would veto any educational reform bill that did not include mandatory consolidation of the state’s 119 school districts, he was placing a big bet on his political strength and the belief that the public’s focus on affordability would push legislators to make the tough choices to reduce what we spend on education. Four months later, with the Legislature in overtime, adjournment looming, and Democrats refusing to budge, Mr. Scott caved.
Why? Because the support for forced consolidation of the state’s school districts isn’t there. And because he’s stepping into the campaign season with most of rural Vermont sensitive to their political standing, something awakened with the Legislature’s forced retreat on Act 181’s land reform effort, and the as-yet-unresolved effect of a health care system that needs trimming.
The education reform bill, H.955, replaces the governor’s mandatory consolidation with a voluntary merger process. It also includes a new education funding formula, which allots the average student the same basic dollar amount, which means voters would no longer decide what their local school districts spend. That would be the state’s responsibility. The bill also includes language addressing other issues, such as state funding for school construction needs.
The governor’s capitulation was not a shock, since he had little support for his mandatory consolidations, but there is scant awareness of exactly what may be included in the bill, what’s to be accomplished, what it might cost, and who has responsibility for what. The bill passed by the Senate was hammered out behind closed doors with little to no public input.
Here’s what we do know: It will not be the subject of much political attention from now until the general election in November. When a legislator, or anyone who is running for office, is asked how the education reform bill addresses affordability or failing academic performance, the response will be that no final decisions have been made, that there are off-ramps for every decision, and that the public’s input is still being gathered. In other words, there’s nothing for you to worry about.
The legislation says that school districts must be involved in the consideration of consolidation, and that may happen, or not. But it’s nothing that’s guaranteed, and it’s an issue easily dodged by candidates, including the governor, who may be skiddish about defending specific consolidation proposals in rural Vermont.
That doesn’t mean the issue of educational reform is part of our past. To the contrary, it just means the can has been kicked down the road, not to be the grenade it was thought to be this political season. Will the voluntary school consolidation process produce the hoped-for savings? Maybe. But the odds are long, given the multiple responses by communities who have already addressed such possibilities. And what are the odds of a foundation formula being put in place by 2029 that dictates what each school district may spend, understanding that such a plan is not only enormously complex but also one with built-in winners and losers? And what about Vermont’s declining test scores? Or the issue of tuitioning students to independent schools?
They remain unaddressed.
We had hoped for better, understanding that the cost and the quality of Vermont’s educational system play an outsized role in its health and prosperity. Figuring out a way for us to talk about it - constructively - remains elusive.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here