When Amanda Janoo was declared the winner in Tuesday’s Democratic primary for governor, she sent a message to everyone paying attention to politics and to the general level of dissatisfaction Vermonters feel with how their lives are being managed. Ms. Janoo’s pithy description of “managed decline” resonated deeply within her political ranks.
We thought her opponent, Aly Richards, would be the more successful challenger to six-term Republican governor Phil Scott. But Ms. Janoo’s early lead and dogged opposition to the status quo found an audience looking for a new face and new ideas.
Ms. Janoo’s margin of victory was thin - less than three percent - and the turnout was meager, with less than one out of every four eligible voters bothering to vote. That makes it hazardous to predict the outcome of the general election 81 days from today. Ms. Janoo is taking on one of the nation’s most popular governors, and someone who has almost equal appeal from independents and moderate Democrats as he does Republicans. He’s able to run for a record-setting seven terms because he has been the moderate viewed as the only defense against the far left and one-party rule.
But even the most popular among us have a shelf life. Mr. Scott included. The negatives begin to accumulate. Patience fades. A fresh face, new ideas, and energy soon take on a serious appeal. The issues may not have changed, but the inertia has.
The polls released during the primary campaign show the governor has lost some of his allure. That’s to be expected. He’s been in the governor’s chair for nine years and was Lieutenant Governor for six years before that. [Someone born his first year in office would be going into their sophomore year in high school.] For voters, that’s familiarity and a sense of trust. It’s also weariness, which is human nature.
As we’ve noted before, Mr. Scott’s strength is his focus. He doesn’t allow the subject to stray from the fundamentals. He’s not exciting, but he’s predictable. Vermonters trust him. He’s honest. They also appreciate his willingness to take on the president. And they know he’s smart enough to poke holes in meritless proposals or ideas that add to Vermont’s high cost of living or simply don’t work.
When Ms. Janoo continues to propose ways to reduce health care costs, or the cost of education, or the need to increase the amount of affordable housing, she will need to be able to do the math. Convincingly. To show how it would work. To show how it wouldn’t drain Vermonters’ bank accounts or push people to places elsewhere. And she will need to do that quickly, capitalizing on Tuesday night’s momentum. She can bet that the governor’s first salvos will be ones challenging her belief that taking from one set of Vermonters and giving it to another set will work. He will be quick to show that Vermonters cannot afford what she’s selling, something that’s untested and, to his mind, radical.
Ms. Janoo is smart, and she has the intensity that draws people to her cause. But what she experienced in the primary will be far different than what she will experience in November’s general election. Those who supported her in the primary are a fraction of the number who will be voting in November. They are not the far-left ideologues. They are the ones in the political middle who will take a close look at her proposals and determine for themselves if they will work or are affordable.
And Mr. Scott will need to combat the ennui that sets in when the public hears the repetition of the same three problems - a lack of housing, costly healthcare, and a troubled and expensive school system - but no answers. There is a reason no governor has ever served a seventh term. It’s the accumulation of negatives twinned with voter fatigue. That will be the governor’s biggest challenge, along with getting out the vote.
Still, the odds are steeply in his favor
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here