This is a no-brainer.
Doubly so for our schools and parents interested in their children’s mental health and social and academic achievements.
It’s a national movement being adopted by several Vermont schools to either forbid cell phones in school or to have them locked up before school begins.
As a general rule most schools in Vermont don’t allow students to use their phones in class, but, as any parent knows, some schools are less concerned about cell phones than others. Schools, and their administrators, are also leery of the pushback a ban would generate from students and their parents. There is also the argument that cell phones have become such an integral part of our lives that banning them in school is tantamount to a retreat in today’s educational landscape.
Several of Vermont’s schools are pushing ahead anyway, following 12 other states that have elected to either ban phones on school property or to restrict them. The reasons are compelling: they worry about the rise in student mental health issues, including suicides, and understand how distracting cell phone use can be in the day-to-day instructional process. [As retro as it may seem, the evidence is conclusive that multi-tasking - being on a cell phone and trying to follow a teacher’s instruction - is a failed strategy.]
The mental health concerns associated with cell phones are not new but the typical response has been to force the tech companies to do a better job regulating their offerings, not limiting the availability of cell phones.
So, how is that going?
It’s not. Nor will it anytime soon.
What’s encouraging is that as time passes and phones become more sophisticated and the apps multiply, parents and educators are becoming more receptive to schools being more restrictive and more open to cell phone bans in schools. In a Vermont Public story, Lamoille South superintendent Ryan Heraty explained how he surveyed the parents in his supervisory union about banning cell phones only to find them overwhelmingly supportive. He said he took it as “almost a mandate” to push forward. Parents are not only interested in protecting their children but are reaching for a sense of control and involvement, keenly aware of the rising instances of anxiety and depression among our youth.
Little wonder. The statistics show the average teen spends eight hours a day on social media, texting, and gaming. That does not include the time spent on school-related assignments. Most of that social media time can be written off as non-productive, to say the least. Additionally, the research shows that most of that time the students are in their rooms, and alone.
Not healthy.
How parents regulate their children’s cell phone use is their choice and no one else’s responsibility. But if schools can make sure students are separated from their phones for at least the amount of time they are in school, that’s a big step toward a better, healthier environment for our children.
Legislation was introduced last year to enact a statewide school cellphone ban and it will be introduced again next year. Whether schools ban cell phones outright or force students to put them in locked pouches until the end of the school day, it’s a move past its time. It’s a no-brainer.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here