It's good that Vermont's AG is in the battle against TikTok

Posted

In 1934 a law was passed that prohibited foreigners or foreign-owned corporations from owning a license to run U.S. radio and television stations. It was passed as a means to counter the propaganda wars of the last century. It was seen as an obvious must during World War II. Few complained it infringed on our Constitutional right to free speech. 

In 1996 the law was updated to deal with a changed world. Yet, today we are in the midst of a similar battle - over the control of information, and its potential impact - with the social media company TikTok and its putative owner, the Chinese government. President Joe Biden has signed into law legislation to force TikTok to either sell its business or cease operation. The deadline for the company's decision is January 19, 2025.

There are a multitude of players involved, which should be expected when dealing with an app that is used by half the American population. It’s wildly popular. Its corporate backers are contesting the law in court, contending, surprise, surprise, that its First Amendment rights would be infringed. The social media company, they argue, is little more than idle entertainment for the multitudes, one that is, of course, massively profitable.

At the same moment, however, the Chinese government’s ulterior motives are becoming so brazen, and so overwhelming, that it’s hard to separate the government from TikTok’s parent company ByteDance. Impossible, actually. 

The Wall Street Journal Monday published a story outlining the scale of China’s espionage activities that are being carried out globally. The paper reports that the espionage is being carried out on an “unprecedented scale.” Chinese hackers, the article says, “outnumber all of the FBI’s cyber personnel at least 50-1.” FBI Director Christopher Wray said, “China’s hacking program is larger than that of every other major nation combined.”

It’s estimated that China’s hacking corp totals somewhere in the vicinity of 600,000 people, or just about the entire population of Vermont.

Yet, frustratingly enough, most Americans are not unsettled by China’s ability, and willingness, to use TikTok for its propaganda purposes. What does catch their attention - at least for some - is the company’s unrelenting effort to mine into the lives of the nation’s youth, particularly teenagers and younger.

Nationally, 20 states have filed lawsuits against TikTok and its parent company ByteDance. Vermont joined the states recently with its own lawsuit and the state’s Attorney General Charity Clark said TikTok’s interface is “a strategic decision that has allowed it to effectively trap young users into cycles of excessive use.” Vermont’s lawsuit alleges that the company’s life-streaming feature has exploited Vermont’s youth sexually and financially.

Most Vermont parents are aware of TikTok’s omniscience. Over 60 percent of U.S. teenagers are on TikTok and according to recent state studies, a third of our high school students spend more than five or more hours a day in front of screens, a fact linked to the rising numbers of children experiencing mental health issues.

In September, Congressional leaders received a letter signed by 40 of the nation’s attorney generals [including Vermont’s], which said “…all of us share an abiding concern for the safety of the kids in our jurisdictions - and algorithm-driven social media platforms threaten that safety.”

Surely the combination of China’s thinly-veiled promise to use espionage to push its ideology across the globe and its unhealthy hold on the nation’s youth are enough to force TikTok to sell to a U.S. company or to cease operations. It’s good that Vermont has joined the push.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here