It's a general election without serious challengers

Posted

Less than a week remains before the filing deadline for major party candidates and it looks as if Vermonters will go to the polls in November without much of a choice; there is not a single statewide race in which the incumbent faces a serious challenge. 

That’s deeply discouraging. No contested races mean there will be little to no debate about the state’s direction. There will be an absence of ideas or creative thought about new approaches to entrenched challenges. There is no need for the incumbents to step outside their lanes. They can play it safe, and they will.

The governor’s race was the last one in question. Former Gov. Howard Dean thought seriously about challenging Gov. Phil Scott but opted out saying it would require a “scorched earth” campaign to beat Mr. Scott, something he was not willing to do. Miro Weinberger, Burlington’s former mayor, was also considering a statewide office but said perhaps another time.

It’s an odd time for would-be challengers to sit at home. The challenges facing Vermont are more acute now than in recent memory. We have a housing crisis. Our educational system is seriously dysfunctional. And our “transitioning” healthcare system is beyond stressed. We continue to be recognized as an expensive place to live. Our demographics continue to work against us. And to change? Well, that’s always been a struggle.

Perhaps that’s part of the reason candidates decide not to run. The challenges are overwhelming and the political topography in Vermont is divisive enough to make running a stomach-churning effort. Then, there is also the mechanics of running a campaign. Raising lots of money is a prerequisite as is being able to simply run a campaign. And then, there is exposure to the uncontrollable side of social media.

But the primary reason Mr. Dean, et al., don’t run is that they see a tortured road to victory. If you can’t win, why run?

We live in a world where it’s all about the victor, ignoring the vital contribution of those who force the debate, those who give Vermonters a choice in November’s general election. How is that healthy for a democracy?

It isn’t. And we need to change the narrative so that challengers are valued for what they bring to the discussion.

We will have four candidates go virtually unchallenged this November: Sen. Bernard Sanders, Rep. Becca Balint, Gov. Phil Scott, and Lt. Gov. David Zuckerman. All are long-term office holders, with the exception of Ms. Balint who is serving her first term. Mr. Sanders will be 83 when he begins his fourth term and will be 90 at the term’s end. Mr. Scott is running for his fifth term as governor, and Mr. Zuckerman is running for his fourth term as Lt. Gov.

In other words, the odds are superb that all four seats will be open when the terms are completed. Typically, people interested in filling any of those positions would be using this time around to get their names known and to build their organizations. 

That was once upon a time. The only “second-tier” person currently serving in a statewide office who is also setting the stage for higher pursuits is State Treasurer Mike Piechak. But that’s two years out, which, in politics, is a lifetime.

To fill the absence of a meaningful debate this election will be a struggle and Vermont will be the poorer for it. To fill that hole will require an outsized effort by the state’s media. Too much hangs in the balance to do otherwise.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here