Is this about unity, or about attention?

Posted

Occasionally, a spark of reason mixed with a little courage makes its way into the public conversation.

It happened last week, on Thursday, when the labor group representing health care and higher education workers came out in opposition to the Vt. AFL-CIO’s decision several days earlier to embrace an aggressive gun rights position, essentially a call to arms to oppose what the labor group sees as a rise in right wing extremists groups.

The executive board of Vermont’s American Federation of Teachers, in response, called out the leadership of the AFL-CIO for its position, saying it promoted violence and that it did not, as AFT President Deb Snell said, “align with our beliefs.”

“It’s like people are looking for trouble. I’m reminded of the laws in the South, the ‘stand your ground’ laws, and how many unnecessary deaths have happened because of that,” Ms. Snell was quoted as saying.

Ms. Snell also noted that over 3,000 AFT members from Vermont have stopped paying their dues since the UNITED slate of officers [led by its president David Van Deusen] assumed control of the labor group two years ago.

“It [the Vt. AFL-CIO] seems to be turning into this more extremist political organization, rather than someone who works for the workers,” Ms. Snell said.

Ms. Snell is correct; there is little debate as to the extreme positions being taken by the UNITED officers elected by the membership. If it’s accurate that over 3,000 AFT members no longer pay their dues, it stands to reason that the extremist position on gun control may spur others to drop their memberships. How is that defensible

if the union’s purpose is to broaden its reach, helping as many workers as it possibly can?

It continues to be a struggle for unions - in Vermont and nationally - to maintain their numbers. Today’s figures show that slightly more than 10 percent of the American workforce belongs to a union, as compared to over 20 percent in 1983, the first year comparable figures were kept. Most union members are public sector workers [34.89 percent] as compared to private sector workers [6.3 percent.] As a state, we rank 20th in the percentage of our workers who belong to a union.

Given the small percentage of Ver- mont workers who belong to a union it’s puzzling why the Vermont chapter of the AFL-CIO, led by Mr. Van Deusen has chosen to follow such extremists positions. But Mr. Van Deusen is not repentant. “The Vermont AFL-CIO does not apologize for our deep commitment to defending democracy, nor for the fact that we practice actual democracy,” he was quoted as saying.

Ms. Snell and her AFT members would probably respond that they are no less patriotic and that their affiliation is as democratically run as his. There is also no disagreement that it’s healthy to have the debate and that organized groups such as the AFL-CIO and its affiliates should take a stand on social issues.

That would help push the Vermont conversation along if the unions and their members were more vocal on causes beyond what affects their pay- checks.

It’s expected that the union representing teachers and state employees would respond when the Legislature considered legislation to deal with their pensions. But it’s a rarity to hear

from the unions when the issue is one of general policy, like how education should be funded, or whether we are on the right track with health care, or how the federal stimulus money could be spent.

In that respect it’s good that the state’s AFL-CIO at least took a position on guns, and on its concern about the proliferation of right wing extremist groups, and its commitment to our democracy. But the Vt. AFL-CIO’s leadership also stresses the need, above all, for unity and not being “fooled by those that want to divide us into antagonistic camps. We know our strength comes from our unity, and from this unity follows true working class power. An injury to one is an injury to all.”

The preaching is good; the practicing what’s being preached is what is lack- ing. If Vermont’s AFT feels strongly

enough about the AFL-CIO’s resolution on guns to publicly oppose it, then the Vt. AFL-CIO's “unity” mission missed its mark. It’s not that outsiders are sowing seeds of discord, it’s the AFL- CIO itself. When the union’s UNITED leadership says it intends to align itself with Vermont’s progressives and to purposely step away from the Democratic Party, that, too, is divisive. There aren’t enough progressives in Vermont to become a unifying front at any significant level. Any substantive progress on the union’s issues will require both progressives and main- stream Democrats.

This begs the question asked by Ms. Snell: Is the UNITED leadership really focused on its 11,000 workers or is this a quixotic venture by the very few at the top who are looking for attention?

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here