How Vt’s environmentalists widen appeal. But will they?

Posted

Legislative leaders say they have heard the voters’ message and will work with Gov. Phil Scott to lower the property tax, perhaps to ensure property tax levels remain unchanged. The leaders' strategy is to confine the voters’ anger to a single issue, school funding. That’s a mistake. Moderating property tax levels, while appealing, is only one part of the overall need to reduce costs. That’s the November election’s message.

That some legislators don’t understand this message is apparent with the reaction to Gov. Phil Scott’s recent announcement that he will work to push back the state’s climate targets, as outlined in both the Clean Heat Standard passed in 2023 and the Global Warming Solutions Act passed in 2020.

The governor says the standards are too rigid and too costly to implement. The law is aimed at the state’s heating sector and a report commissioned by the Department of Public Service pegged the overall cost of the program to a little over $9 billion. The study also noted it would be problematic to administer.

No one knows the exact cost consumers would be asked to bear should the Legislature vote to implement the law this session. What we do know is that weatherizing homes and installing heat pumps in Vermont’s homes is an expensive venture. What we do know is that those increased fuel costs will be substantial and an immediate source of voter opposition. A 50 cents per gallon charge initially, and higher after that, has that effect.

The governor wants to delay the 2030 emission levels which would require us to lower our carbon emissions to 40 percent below our 1990 levels. He would also like to get rid of the law that allows anyone to sue the state should the state not meet any of the law’s standards, [one of the dumbest things ever.]

The environmental community and its legislative adherents pitch the issue as the session’s biggest battle. As a coalition, they are second to none in their influence and their reach and they intend to make the battle a test of one’s commitment to the environment. Opponents, including the governor, will be labeled as lackeys to the fossil fuel industry or global warming denialists.

That’s also a mistake and deeply unfortunate. Particularly for those who appreciate the need for cleaner air and water, reduced emissions, and a world more committed to the struggle against global warming. 

We don’t know yet what the governor has in mind when he says he wants to push the 2030 deadline back. Reacting in advance is ridiculous. It also raises the potential of Vermonters being pushed away from environmentalist causes. If, for example, the governor proposed delaying the 2030 deadline back five years, and, in the process, brought along the support of his backers, would that not be a stronger coalition and one more trusting of its leadership?

It would. In fact, it would be an opportunity that would benefit the environmental movement immensely. To do otherwise, to insist that the existing deadlines be met and that the costs be ignored would brand the environmental lobby writ large as elitist and out of touch in Vermont’s world of high costs and lack of affordability. 

So why would the environmental lobbying prefer the battle? It’s how they raise their money. In this case, it may be how they lose the battle and fail to grow their following, a Hobbesian strategy that defeats their purpose and weakens the fight against global warming.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here