How to keep the progress on health care reform alive

Posted

It’s hard to pinpoint when Vermont’s healthcare system began its painful turn from something guaranteed to fail to something that may survive. Was it the Oliver Wyman report commissioned by the Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB] that warned of impending doom if hospitals did not change how they do business? Was it the threat of BlueCross Blue Shield of Vermont plunging into bankruptcy? Was it the Legislature passing legislation in an effort to limit what hospitals could charge? Was it the GMCB making it clear that Vermonters could not afford to pay the nation’s highest healthcare premiums, and, hence, the regulators began to say no to hospitals and insurers?

In truth, all played a role. It’s too large a task for one player to effect change on their own. But the takeaway is that change is coming. Thankfully. It’s unavoidable. The system doesn’t work. What we have is too expensive, and that pain has finally made its way down to those paying the bills. Us. And we’re becoming more vocal.

As the anger/fear begins to bubble its way up the political ladder, those vested with the responsibility to change the status quo are emboldened. Gov. Phil Scott Thursday, released a statement saying, “By making healthcare more affordable, the Green Mountain Care Board will play a critical role in revitalizing Vermont’s county economic centers and the smaller towns around them. As they review hospital budgets, we urge the board to contain them to the lowest responsible level.”

Legislators are reacting similarly. When regulators know they have the public’s support, all the way to the governor’s office, it helps clear the road of the typical obfuscations that limit progress, chief among them being the lack of dependable, verifiable information. 

There are two forces that have contributed substantially to the debate. One is the Liaison Team set up as part of a settlement between regulators and the UVM Health Network, and headed by former Human Services Secretary Mike Smith. The second is the VHC911 group put together by former Gov. Jim Douglas and Lisa Ventriss, former chair of the Vermont Business Roundtable.

Both have made understanding the University of Vermont Health Network’s operations and its profound impact on the rest of the state their primary goal. UVMHN’s multi-billion-dollar operation controls all. To not understand that is to forfeit any understanding of how healthcare reform can succeed in Vermont.

Both have also called out the state’s healthcare Goliath for its profligacy. They have done so just before the GMCB makes its decision on UVMHN’s 2026 budget. Mr. Smith was particularly pointed in his criticism, essentially saying the hospital was telling the public it was cutting its total costs when, in fact, it was not. Both have also pointed to the fact that, as of the third quarter of 2025, the hospital network has generated $1.7 billion in net unrestricted assets [as a non-profit, that money can be spent anyway they’d like] and has $1.4 billion in unrestricted cash and investments. In other words, the network has the wherewithal to make healthcare “affordable for Vermonters.”

So if the immediate signs point to a clearer understanding of what needs to happen to protect and strengthen the state’s healthcare system, and to make it affordable for Vermonters, then what’s the concern? 

Time. Lack of communication. Lapsing into old habits. Who keeps the charge alive? 

Here is a suggestion: Have the GMCB invest some taxpayer dollars to establish a top-flight communication team whose responsibility it is to keep the public informed as to the challenges, the progress, the setbacks, etc., that beset the industry and affect the public. Health care in Vermont makes up 20 percent of the state’s GDP; does it not make sense to have a handle on how it works and what it costs?

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here