How pricing transparency could cut healthcare costs

Posted

In November’s general election Democrats lost more seats in Vermont than any other state. The reason was the state’s sky-high cost of living. Democratic leaders are turning themselves inside out to make sure Vermonters understand they heard their message.

It borders on being a Sisyphean task in the near term. School budgets have already been drawn up and hospitals are nearing the end of their calendar years. Gov. Phil Scott, a Republican, will control not only the budget but the narrative. All he has to do is question the cost of something and the advantage becomes his.

Ideally, both sides will identify a common goal and do the necessary work, forgoing the urge for a zero-sum victory. In a politically polarized world that’s difficult. Even in Vermont. But this week the Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB] may have struck upon an opportunity. Or at least a start.

The board was tasked by the Legislature to deliver a report on Reference Based Pricing [RBP] for healthcare providers. It was to analyze the impact RBP would have on the approximately 60,000 state and school employees represented by VSEA and VEHI.

Reference-based pricing is a pricing strategy that establishes a benchmark, like Medicare, and sets reference prices across the healthcare system as a percentage of that benchmark. The information is public, allowing patients to see what a particular procedure would cost at each of Vermont’s hospitals. It’s an incentive for hospitals to lower their prices, seeing what their competitors charge.

The GMCB worked the numbers concluding that over the five years studied the savings would have been $400 million. The math wasn’t complicated. Hospital payments for the two groups averaged 289 percent of what Medicare charges. The board reduced that multiple to 200 percent and tallied the difference.

That’s a lot of savings for 60,000 employees to generate. The most recent year of the study, 2022, showed a savings of $79 million. Spin that forward another year and it’s obvious that would have made a difference to Vermonters and perhaps to Democrats in the last election. Think of the possibilities, if all Vermonters channeled their healthcare needs through an RBP system.

For legislators looking to please their constituents this qualifies. 

But, as with all such things, it is complicated. It can’t be done in haste. It can’t be done and not protect the health of our hospitals. It can’t be done without eventually including all parties, not just VSEA and VEHI employees. It’s a transformative process and care has to be taken not to make things worse by acting too quickly. The good news is that Vermont would not be breaking new ground. Six states have embraced the RBP system at one level or another. Legislators can pick through their examples to learn what worked best.

It’s also a distinct advantage to have the GMCB offer its qualified support. As the state’s healthcare regulator, it has a keen awareness of the healthcare system’s needs. Its mission is to have our healthcare community provide quality care at an affordable price. Their guidance to legislators could be pivotal in ensuring something that works. Perhaps this could be a two-year framework that gave hospitals breathing room to get their operations in place in the near term knowing that the new pricing system would be in place soon afterwards. If so, this would help soften the tension between the board and hospitals, with both sides understanding what the other party wants and can afford.

For those of us interested in the continued health of our own hospital, an RBP system could work to Northwestern Medical Center’s benefit. NMC is already the state’s low-cost healthcare provider. A transparent pricing system would solidify that reputation and perhaps strengthen NMC’s hold on the Franklin County market and beyond. It could also be a good recruitment tool. 

In sum, Vermont is in dire need of strategies that reduce our costs. Healthcare leads the list. Our healthcare premiums are double the national average. An RBP system could reduce our costs, an outcome that would trickle down into the pockets of all Vermonters.

That should draw the attention of our legislators.

By Emerson Lynn

#sanl

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here