How popular will spending cuts be? Not very.

Posted

In November’s election 50 percent of the votes cast for President-elect Donald Trump were from families with yearly incomes of less than $50,000. This was a dramatic shift from past elections. This same cohort went big for Joe Biden, plus 11 percent, Hillary Clinton, 12 percent, and Barack Obama, 22 percent. The reason? Low-income families believe the Trump administration will take better care of them than Democrats.

To make that happen the new administration will need to protect their benefits, the communities in which they live, and even their jobs. 

That will be a heavy lift, as we saw earlier this month when Congress struggled to pass a spending bill to keep the government funded until March. As insistent as Mr. Trump, and his budget-cutting disciple Elon Musk were, the end product wasn’t anything close to restrained spending.

Mr. Musk’s goal [as co-head of Trump’s Department of Government Efficiency [DOGE] is to cut spending by two trillion dollars but Mr. Trump has already made it clear that government entitlement programs like Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, etc., will be spared. [In the last moments of the session, Congress passed a bill that would expand Social Security for some public-sector employees. That move alone will cost the program another $220 billion over the next decade.]

It’s true the nation has a $6.75 trillion spending problem. The federal deficit hit $1.8 trillion at the end of the last fiscal year, which is 6.4 percent of the nation’s GDP. The interest on that debt is roughly $882 billion, which is a sizable chunk of the $6.75 trillion budget. Of the remaining amount, $4.1 trillion goes to mandatory spending, which includes Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, food stamps, pensions, veterans’ benefits, and subsidies for the Affordable Care Act. The discretionary spending - what Congress argued about last week - is about $2 trillion.

So how will the Trump/Musk team cut two trillion dollars in government spending?

Good question. We’ve been discussing the need to rein in government spending for as long as most of us have been alive. To no avail. Why? Because receiving checks from Uncle Sam is more popular than sending checks to Uncle Sam. We like receiving more than giving. 

That 50 percent that makes less than $50,000 annually? That’s a large swath of the American population and it would be next to impossible to make meaningful cuts to the budget without having them bear part of the burden. And does anyone truly believe Mr. Trump, et al, will be ripping a page from Bernie Sanders’ book calling for a tax on the rich? Have you seen the level of wealth among his cabinet selections? They look like givers to you?

And does anyone believe Mr. Trump’s claim that he will make the cuts by eliminating waste, fraud, and abuse? Will he use his executive office authority to make these cuts on his own, including the reversal of President Biden’s actions? Here’s an example of the difficulty he faces: President Biden has proposed that Medicare and Medicaid cover anti-obesity drugs, which will cost an estimated $140 billion annually. Mr. Trump will have the option of canceling the proposal. But the proposal has strong support among Americans and strong bipartisan support in Congress. So what’s the guess? Up, or down?

As we know, Mr. Trump hates doing unpopular things. He wants to be everyone’s hero. While cutting government spending sounds heroic, making the actual cuts means someone gets less. Lots of us. 

How will Mr. Trump spin that tale?

By Emerson Lynn

  

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here