How NOT to be responsible environmentally

Posted

On May 1, 2025, Julie Moore, secretary of Vermont’s Agency of Natural Resources, was sued by the United States and the Environmental Protection Agency for “standing in the way” of the nation’s effort to secure sources of domestic energy. The culprit was Vermont’s enactment of the “Climate Superfund Act,” which seeks to hold major fossil fuel companies financially responsible for the damages caused by their greenhouse gas emissions. The government contends that the legislation has the potential to control emissions nationally, even across the globe.

Ms. Moore has a solid reputation as an environmentalist, and she finds herself in a frustrating position. Just as she faces the lawsuit from the federal government, she’s also in the middle of a court battle at home over the Global Warming Solutions Act [GWSA] passed by the Legislature in 2020.

Both laws deal with emission levels. Ms. Moore would like nothing more than to work on these laws and lower the state’s emissions. That’s part of the job. Instead, she finds herself spending time and the taxpayers’ dollars in court. 

An appropriate example is the GWSA, which included a key provision allowing anyone in Vermont to sue the state if they thought the state was not meeting the law’s requirements. It was one of the dumbest things the Legislature has ever done. 

As predicted, the Conservation Law Foundation filed suit against the state late last year, alleging Ms. Moore failed to change the rules necessary for the state to meet its greenhouse gas emission levels for 2025.

Thankfully, Vermont Superior Court Judge Timothy Tomasi recently ruled against the CLF and in favor of the state’s motion to dismiss the suit. He ruled that Ms. Moore’s agency was responsible for enforcing the law’s deadlines but was not obligated to rework the rules to change or advance the outcomes.

The ruling was a win for the state. But it’s temporary. It’s a given that the state will fail to meet the 2025 standards, and those set for 2030 as well. So we can expect the CLF to sue the state again when the results are confirmed.

Is that a good use of taxpayers’ money? No, it’s not. When the Legislature convenes in January, its priority should be to repeal the private right to sue provision and, frankly, to rework the state’s emission levels to a reasonable level.

But there is even a bigger issue in play, and that’s recognizing the need for the state’s environmental community to change its ways and figure out how to work with the state to make progress lowering emissions. The enemy is not Ms. Moore or the Scott administration. It’s Trump. 

The president is in the early stages of eliminating subsidies for most of our environmental efforts. It’s cutting subsidies for electric car purchases and EV stations. It’s cutting subsidies for renewable power. Car manufacturers have been given the green light to get back into the business of making gas-guzzlers. The Trump team doesn’t really want the EPA regulating greenhouse gas emissions at all.

In other words, that stream of cash coming in from the federal government is about to disappear. The hole for Vermont to fill has just gotten much deeper. Meeting the 2030 emission standards, for example, is guaranteed to be incredibly expensive, something that should be made clearer by the middle of the next legislative session [and the beginning of the political season.]

So, when the environmentalists, led by the CLF,  lead the charge on the Climate Superfund Act and when they continue to champion the right of individuals to sue the state if our emission levels fall short, they not only are costing the taxpayers a lot of money, but they are also making it next to impossible to achieve any of the state’s environmental goals.

That’s been the way of the Conservation Law Foundation and other environmental groups. It`s how they raise their money. They set the goal posts far beyond what’s achievable, let alone affordable. Meanwhile, our air, land, and water go untended. How is that defensible?

We have another three-plus years to deal with the Trump administration and its anti-environmental siege. If we are to make any progress, it will require our environmentalists to become more responsible. Spending more time in court does not meet that test.

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here