How NMC can be used to lower health care costs

Posted

Vermont’s Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB] is the state’s health care regulator, whose job it is to cap the budgets of the state’s hospitals and insurers. The board’s goal is to moderate the impact on what Vermonters pay for healthcare. So it’s unusual for the board to encourage a hospital to spend more, particularly in the non-medical area of public engagement or basic marketing.

But that’s what the board has suggested for Northwestern Medical Center. It’s for the best of “reduced healthcare cost” reasons.

Why? Because a significant percentage of the Franklin County healthcare market travels to the University of Vermont Medical Center for their care rather than to Northwestern Medical Center. That’s an expensive choice, according to the GMCB’s fact-gathering efforts. For example, it costs $6,520 on average for an MRI at UVMMC. The same service costs $2,785 at NMC. The service offered to patients is the same at both.

So, who pays that $4,000 difference? We all do. Every time it happens. This is why the state’s largest insurer, Blue Cross Blue Shield of Vermont, has started its own statewide campaign to inform Vermonters about the price differences between providers and encourage patients to pick the lowest-cost provider. The company uses the cost differences between UVM and NMC as one of the best examples of the available savings.

The campaign is overdue. Our health care premiums are the nation’s highest and double the national average. The money we spend on premiums affects much of our spending - everything from property taxes to labor costs to groceries and the cost of living.

Why is it so difficult to change behavior? What do we need to do in Franklin County, for example, to get people to go to NMC and not UVMMC for their MRIs?

The research shows that 40 percent of all healthcare visits can be scheduled in advance, which means there is time to consider the option and choose the lower-cost service. But that’s not going to happen unless the patient is aware of the choice and is guided by someone they trust, i.e., their doctor. And it’s not going to happen if NMC’s marketing campaign is limited in scope, duration, or funding. It takes time and resources to change people’s behaviors, whether they are patients or doctors.

That said, several questions/options seem worth exploring:

  • Our schools are among the largest employers in Franklin County, and almost all their employees belong to a union. Their contracts are negotiated on a statewide basis, but is there not a way for school districts to inform, or incentivize their employees, as to the cost advantage of using NMC for their procedures? And isn’t this something the VTNEA should be doing statewide, since healthcare costs are part of the reason our school budgets are among the nation’s costliest?
  • The same questions can be asked of state employees. The Vermont State Employees Association represents hundreds of employees in Franklin County. Could, for example, the employees get a reduction in their copays if they chose the low-cost provider [NMC] when applicable? The state has a line of communication that goes directly to each of its employees. Isn’t this something that could be done statewide?
  • Each Franklin County municipality has the same opportunity. They should be championing NMC’s cost advantages not only as a means to reduce healthcare premiums, but as a way to support one of the county’s largest and most important employers. It’s a way to connect the dots between individual choice and community affordability.
  • Perhaps most important would be the communication between our primary care providers and their patients at the moment of referral. If our providers told the patients that going to NMC for the MRI [or any similar procedure] would yield the same results, but would save the system money, research shows that most patients would always choose the local option. Again, that speaks directly to the GMCB’s need to reduce spending, which would help BCBS mitigate the rise in its premiums. Isn’t that a consideration that’s part of the understood relationship between NMC and its doctors?

These options should be considered as ideas that not only could reduce healthcare costs, but also could weave together parts of the Vermont community in the common pursuit of a better and more affordable healthcare system.

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here