A decade ago Northwestern Medical Center had 360 days cash on hand, the most of any hospital in Vermont. NMC also routinely proposed the smallest rate increase of all the state’s 14 hospitals. Financially, it was regarded as one of Vermont’s strongest hospitals. Fast forward to today and NMC finds itself in the red with projections that it will be operating 14 percent below its margin by 2028, four short years away.
What happened?
The answer centers around the state’s quickly changing demographics, a regulatory reform process that, at times, was less than ideal, and, frankly, a lack of statewide leadership.
All of Vermont’s hospitals have been affected similarly; it’s not NMC’s problem by its lonesome. [In NMC’s case, it didn’t help when the Green Mountain Care Board ordered NMC to slash its cash on hand and to reduce its rates, a process from which NMC never fully recovered.]
Today, nine of the state’s 14 hospitals are losing money and the Green Mountain Care Board is making the rounds to make sure the communities affected understand the severity of today’s crisis. The board was in St. Albans last week to do just that and to make clear that any resurrection would require monumental changes in the way our healthcare system works.
There were several takeaways from GMCB’s presentation, but the largest among them is our demographics. We’re not growing, we’re not adding enough young people to offset the increased number of elderly. As was noted in a Messenger story this week, by 2040 there will be 26 percent fewer working-age people in NMC’s coverage area.
And we are one of Vermont’s youngest counties. Think what that means statewide. As we age, the percentage of those who need care rises. This particular demographic is also sicker which means more care at a higher cost. Providers have little choice but to raise rates.
When the GMCB met in St. Albans, board chair Owen Foster acknowledged the challenge saying: “...in a nation with some of the worst healthcare costs in the world, Vermont is one of the states with the most expensive health care… No other state is looking at the demographic and expense growth trends and trying to envision a delivery system that can both meet community needs and withstand headwinds financially that are coming its way. No other state is seeking such comprehensive and innovative solutions. So this is a time of opportunity and choice.”
We have been here before, but the stakes then were not as high as they are now. We set up OneCare Vermont to be the organizing force to push hospitals away from fee-for-service to a capitated payment system which would essentially pay hospitals based on the number of people served. That would place the incentive on preventative care, placing primary care physicians at the tip of the healthcare spear.
It’s still a work in progress, just glacially slow. Why?
It was noted in the GMCB presentation that housing was also an issue. It’s tough for hospitals to recruit physicians and nurses if they have no place to live. The Legislature passed a bill this past session to address that need, but absolutely no one believes it addresses the issue with the necessary force and funding.
And, as we all know, Vermont has a basic problem with the idea of growth. If we oppose the idea of new housing developments how will we ever solve the problem of having more old and sick people than young and healthy? How will we ever deal with the expense of keeping schools open that have too few students?
Mr. Foster is to be commended for coming to St. Albans to speak directly to the future of NMC. The hospital is not only one of our largest employers but is central to our economic development county-wide. It’s a given that some of our employers would not be here if the community didn’t have a first-class hospital. That presence applies to future growth as well. As a community, it’s vital to have a hospital within our midst and not be forced to travel to Burlington for care.
But to nurse our health care system back to health requires a level of leadership that has been missing. The Green Mountain Care Board has to be part of that process, but its role has limited policy chops. The healthcare community is understandably hobbled by various struggles of self-interest. Who lays out the vision? Who builds the either/or picture that brings us together?
We don’t have a lot of time to figure this out. The majority of our hospitals are operating in the red and the average Vermonter is struggling to pay the month’s insurance premiums. The only thing that’s clear is that what we have doesn’t work and that every year that passes without progress is a year where hospitals like NMC become more vulnerable.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here