No matter the state, the common denominator for those who live in its rural areas is dependency on those who feed us, our farmers. Those farmers, in turn, have a common denominator dependency of their own, which is an undocumented workforce. It’s estimated that 40 percent to 70 percent of those who work on our farms are here illegally.
So when eight migrant farm workers were detained by the U.S. Customs and Border Protection agents last week, it sent a shudder down the spines of those who understand just how dependent our farmers are on migrant labor. Our dairy farmers would be hard-pressed to get their work done without them.
The migrants detained were from the St. Pierre farm in Berkshire, one of the largest farms in Franklin County. The only “good” news is that the detainments didn’t appear to be part of the Trump administration’s plan to deport those here illegally. The CBP officials were responding to a tip about an alleged border crossing, which led the officials to the farm located near the border.
Still, as a matter of historical practice, farm workers detained were typically released in short order unless they were “a threat to our national security, public safety, and border security.” That’s not been the case with the eight detained last week. They are still in custody, which puts everyone on edge. Farmers don’t know whether their workers are being targeted by the president’s new policies on “noncitizens.” Migrant workers [and their families] who have been here for years are understandably terrified they could be deported. And Vermonters in general are worried [or should be] that its farmers would be harmed by the loss of roughly half their workforce.
Gov. Phil Scott weighed in on the government’s actions saying, “While I believe those who are here illegally and are committing serious crimes should be detained, and, I don’t believe we should be targeting those who are here peacefully, because they’re our neighbors and friends, have kids in our schools, shop at our businesses and play an important role in our economy and workforce.”
The governor has also called upon the administration to expand the country’s work visa program. “It’s far past time. We kicked the can down the road long enough and somebody has to be the adult here and step up.”
It’s an easy answer to the challenge at hand. Congress is actively considering a bill to expand work visas and provide legal status pathways for undocumented farmer workers already working as farm laborers without authorization.
What’s puzzling is that the bill isn’t being rushed through. It’s the country’s rural areas that gave the president his strongest levels of support in the November election. America’s most farming-dependent areas supported Mr. Trump by an average of almost 78 percent. Yet, one of the first things the president did was to shut down USAID, which bought two billion dollars worth of farm products. And now Mr. Trump is going after their workers, lumping them in with alleged criminals connected with the world’s drug cartels?
It’s a given that the Trump administration has no interest in moderating immigration policies but it’s also shown its sensitivity to policies that rock the financial markets or stress particular businesses, i.e., the auto industry. In the president's first term, he also showed a sensitivity to farmers hurt by his trade policies.
Perhaps that’s Mr. Scott’s opening. He is co-chair of the National Governors Association’s Public Health and Disaster Response Task Force, which oversees Homeland Security, Immigration, and Human Services. Could he not push his fellow governors to encourage the president to steer his immigration efforts away from farm labor, something that all governors would support?
It’s not a fight Mr. Scott can mount himself. He’s from deep blue Vermont. He’s on record as voting for Kamala Harris, not Donald Trump. And he is dealing with a vengeful president. His best chance would be to use his popularity with the nation’s governors on an issue that benefits them all, including the president.
The last thing we need is for the eight migrant farmers being held at the Northwest State Correctional Facility to be joined by other farm laborers.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here