As the Legislature limps to adjournment, the focus of both parties is the strength or weakness they will shoulder going into November’s election. Democrats want to avoid a repeat of the 2024 election, where they lost their supermajorities. Republicans sense an opportunity to improve their numbers in both the House and Senate, again riding Gov. Phil Scott’s affordability agenda. Meanwhile, there is the sense that the Democrats are in retreat. The money is gone, budgets are tight, and they are being called to task for actions past.
It’s debatable whether either party can deal with Vermont’s core issues, most of which center on the state’s troublesome demographics. Neither party has a conclusive answer to the state’s urgent need to attract more people. Neither party has the answer to how our schools should be configured to cost less and be better. The same applies to the state’s expensive health care system.
What we do know, however, is that the politics currently favor any argument that puts money into people’s pockets, and, conversely, opposes any suggestion that we pay more. That’s essentially the reason Mr. Scott is finishing his fifth term as governor.
The issue that no one saw coming - at least to its present level - is the current effort to repeal key sections of Act 181, the legislation passed last session that was intended to reform Act 250. The Legislature’s Rural Caucus has turned Montpelier upside down, drawing opposition from our rural environs, centered on the perceived loss of property rights and the advantages conferred to Vermont’s urban centers.
The Dems have conceded the fight and are on track to repeal the law’s most troublesome sections, in the process casting aside their long-held relationships with the state’s environmental groups. It’s not that the environmental groups will line up behind Mr. Scott, but the loss could sap some of their energy and cost the Democrats some needed campaign support.
What’s odd about the capitulation is that the Democratic leadership is trying to recover by pointing out that the governor is guilty of the same anti-rural sins with his push to use a “top-down” approach to school reform by pushing for a consolidation of Vermont’s 119 school districts into five. The Dems point to the governor’s hypocrisy, saying rural communities would lose their schools because they might no longer have their own school boards or any local control.
Equating the two is ridiculous. Do the Dems intend to suggest that school consolidation at any level is injurious to the state and to rural Vermont? Do they intend to fight any educational reform measure that leads to a small rural school closing its doors, choosing instead to align itself with a neighboring school with a larger student population? What’s their answer to an educational system that has become one of the nation’s most expensive, despite the fact that we’re educating about 30 percent fewer children since the mid-1990s, and our educational standards have dropped to the bottom quintile? Are the Dems really arguing that all things should be seen as equal if the governor gives up his call for consolidation, allowing Act 181 to continue in place, as written?
These are the questions voters will be asking the next six months, and they will not be misled by politicians who paint false comparisons. The voters are extraordinarly sensitive to any effort that doesn’t add value, and doesn’t do it in a way that raises the prosperity of the people who live here.
There is a reason Mr. Scott, a Republican, has served as long as he has. Even in the deeply blue state of Vermont. Dems need to figure out a way to oppose him that doesn’t alienate them from the voters. They need to figure out a way to “out-Scott” Phil Scott.
Their current trajectory puts them further from their target, not closer.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here