How best to spend Meta's $92M 'gift'?

Posted

 It’s a start.

This week, it was announced that over the next decade Vermont would receive over $92 million from Meta to stop knowingly putting our children in harm’s way. The checks coming Vermont’s way are part of a $18 billion class action suit filed in 2023 by 47 states to address the addictive qualities of Meta’s social media platforms.

Meta’s capitulation was a shocker. Few expected the social media giant to give up given its almost bottomless pockets. And it’s a dead certainty the company didn’t give up because it discovered its conscience.

Meta’s settlement didn’t come with an apology. By settling and not having to say the company did anything wrong, it avoided the possibility of a jury awarding far more than the settlement. Besides, Meta brings in $200 billion a year in revenue. It’s an operational cost that’s manageable. 

What was clever, and in the end highly beneficial to the cause, is Meta’s insistence that 30 percent of the financial package [roughly 30 percent or $5.3 billion] is contingent on YouTube and TikTok agreeing to identical safety terms. Either the other social media competitors accept the youth limits [midnight lockouts, hard caps, limited school use time, etc.] or face the same financial penalties.

If this happens, perhaps we will make some progress on the mental health front for our children. And no longer will the social media companies be able to hide behind free speech arguments and continue their deceit about violating children’s privacy laws, etc.

It’s a big deal. Meta, et al, will be required to institute hard caps on daily time limits for minors; they will have to silence their push notifications during school hours, reduce their social comparison mechanics considerably, like counting their “likes.” And they will be forced to appoint an independent auditor whose responsibility it will be to make sure the social media companies comply with the settlement’s language.

Why the focus on our youth? Well, because the average teenager spends an average of 4.8 hours per day on social media platforms like TikTok, YouTube, Instagram, Facebook, etc. Children even younger - ages 8-12 spend an average of 5.5 hours of daily screen time, most of it on social media sites. The social media giants develop algorithms meant to keep them flipping from one screen to another, one reel to the next, endlessly. They are almost on their screens more than they are asleep.

Requiring Meta and its competitors to stop the notifications and alerts during nighttime hours or when they are in school is basically common sense. Parents have been complaining about this for years but to no avail. The companies insisted it couldn’t be done and still remain in business.

Guess that wasn’t true either. 

If they can spend hundreds of billions a year to build data centers, it’s probably a sure thing they can free enough cash to change their algorithms so that children - their future customers - aren’t hurt.

Seems like a good PR move, right?

There are two challenges for Vermont and perhaps all other states. The first is our children. They’re smart. They’ve been raised in a digital universe. Meta may have made the calculation that kids will figure out workarounds no matter what Meta does. So let them. Second is the willingness of the states -including Vermont - to actually spend Meta’s checks where it makes a difference, which is our children’s mental health. 

We’ve been here before. Vermont has received multi-million dollar payouts each year since 1998 from the tobacco companies, money intended to reduce usage and money intended to treat the addiction. So far, we’ve received over $840 million. Last April, this year’s check was for $22.1 million, which is more than double what we will get from Meta on a yearly basis. 

Has the tobacco settlement money always been used for its intended purpose? Not a chance. The legislature decides how to allocate the yearly amounts. 

Enough said.

Charity Clark, Vermont’s attorney general, has the lead on the issue. She played a meaningful part in bringing Meta to task. Let’s hope she continues the fight and makes sure the roughly $10 million annually is spent where it can do the most good.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here