When the Legislature’s 10-person Joint Fiscal Committee met last week to address how the state will respond to federal cuts to the state’s human services programs, it was clear no one knew the extent of the cuts and their impact. The Scott administration thought the cuts would be less than feared. Sen. Bernie Sanders’ representative didn’t see how the state would be able to handle the onslaught coming its way.
Whatever happens will have little bearing on this year’s budget. Most of the proposed cuts will be feathered out over the next decade. The Legislature’s task is to look ahead and put in place a budget that addresses the challenges the president’s federal budget creates.
It would be a welcome relief if the cuts produced less havoc than feared. When the president’s tax and spending bill passed Congress, state officials said it would cause 45,000 people in Vermont to lose their health insurance. Jenney Samuelson, Secretary of the Vermont Agency of Human Services, thinks the 45,000 figure is high and that it’s prompting unnecessary fear, yet did not offer a clear projection of what that figure might be.
Rep. Emilie Kornheiser, D-Brattleboro, chair of the Joint Fiscal Committee, is pessimistic about the impact of cuts coming Vermont’s way and prefers to figure out ways to deal with the shortages in advance.
Ms. Samuelson’s thoughts are probably closer to the truth, but Ms. Kornheiser’s approach is correct: assume the worst and develop a plan to deal with it. And go a step further. Instead of figuring out how to stem the cuts’ effects in next year’s budget, develop a plan for the next five years. We have this president for the next three and a half years. It’s unlikely he will repent and restore past funding levels. We may not know exactly what will happen to Medicaid’s funding, but it is a safe bet we’d be better off planning for less and then being pleasantly surprised if the numbers improve. We know how that story ends.
Although the Joint Fiscal Committee is focusing on the potential damage to the state’s human services programs, the financial threat to Vermont’s well-being goes far beyond the cuts to Medicare.
We still don’t know how President Trump’s tariff war on Canada will evolve. If it were extended to energy, that could have a meaningful impact on costs to Vermonters. [We’ve already been stung by the precipitous drop in tourism.]
We’ve spent $800 million over the last nine years on homelessness, yet the number of those without shelter continues to rise. How much more needs to be spent? How is it to be spent?
Legislation has been signed into law that would redo the state’s educational system. The purpose is to reduce costs and improve the quality of the education being offered. The state also has a roughly $6 billion bill for deferred maintenance on schools whose structures need repair. How can future state budgets be structured to meet these needs?
We have a workplace shortage, no available housing, a high cost of living, and a quickly aging population. How are these factors being worked into the next decade’s budgeting?
And, perhaps most relevant, August is the month when all the state’s hospitals pass their proposed budgets through the Green Mountain Care Board for review. Vermont’s health care system constitutes almost 20 percent of the state’s GDP, and there is no part of our economy under greater stress. If, for example, Medicaid does push 45,000 Vermonters off health care, they will get their care from a hospital’s emergency room, and, in the main, it will ultimately be written off as free care. How do we budget that? If the health care premiums continue to soar, how does that affect the workplace, or school budgets, or Vermont’s ability to attract new workers? If Vermont’s hospitals continue to reduce the number of employees and continue to cut services, how is that being approached by the 10 members of the Joint Fiscal Committee?
In short, none of the costs can be separated from Vermont’s budget; the state is the financier that has its fingers on the pulse of all these issues. It’s the first week of August, roughly 20 weeks remain before the Legislature convenes. The Joint Fiscal Committee has its work cut out for it.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here