How a few changed Vt's broken DCF system

Posted

As the Legislature prepares for its veto session on June 17th the focus is on the differences between what the governor and legislators think is appropriate, affordable, and achievable. It’s the last gasp of the legislative session.

While the veto session is understandably a reflection of differences it’s also worth noting that occasionally bills are signed into law that right a wrong. 

Truly.

That happened this week when Gov. Phil Scott signed into law H.661, a bill that changes “investigation and substantiation standards” used by the Vermont Department for Children and Families [DCF] when children are separated from parents accused of neglect or abuse.

The bill was passed unanimously by both the House and Senate and had the strong support of the governor whose agency - DCF - will now be required to change how it operates. No small thing.

It’s the first time in 40 years that the agency has been told to change the way it operates. How that happened is important to understand and to applaud. It did not happen because the agency recognized the error of its ways. It happened because a tiny group of citizens familiar with the system recognized the wrongs for what they were: egregious and unjust. The group was headed up by Larry Crist, executive director of the Vermont Parent Representation Center, who knew how difficult it would be to prove the agency’s misdeeds, let alone be able to get the governor and the Legislature to agree on how the system should be changed.

Mr. Crist set up what was called “The Substantiation Project”, a multi-year effort to filter through 30 appeals from parents judged by DCF as guilty of child abuse or neglect. As we have noted in editorials before on this issue, DCF lost in every single case. All 30 appeals. All were overturned. 

This became the grist that made the legislation possible. No one could dispute how flawed DCF’s procedures were. There were also a lot of victims, parents whose names were placed on the child protection registry who were not guilty. There are 25,000 names on that registry, how many were falsely accused?

Mr. Crist’s efforts were central to the legislation that evolved. Without the project, nothing would have changed. He also had the vocal support of Bill Young who served for years as head of DCF and whose support as a bureaucratic insider was crucial. While both were vital in pushing things forward, the most timely support came from Chris Winters who had just been appointed Commissioner of DCF in May of 2023. Mr. Winters did a review of the 30 appeal cases and came to the same conclusion: His own department was operating under faulty guidelines. His own system was broken.

Legislators saw the obvious. The committees responsible for the proposed legislation did their due diligence. They worked with all parties to set in place procedures that would protect all parties and change the rules and procedures for those put on the Child Protection Registry. The law also addresses how someone’s name would be removed.

It’s encouraging to know there are people willing to move the mountains in front of them to get things done. The right things. It’s encouraging to see the Legislature respond in kind and to have the governor sign his name to a new law that raises the performance level of one of his agencies.

The law is in place. The task now is to make sure DCF follows it.

By Emerson Lynn

 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here