There were three “imperatives’ cited in the consultant’s report on what would be necessary for Vermont to transform its healthcare system into something sustainable. The first was the need to build housing. The second was to have hospitals go to “reference-based” pricing and the third was to “move all care possible out of hospitals.”
At first blush, it would seem odd to list housing as the number one priority in a healthcare crisis. But the consultant was looking to the future saying: “Foundational infrastructure including a robust workforce, greater access to transportation, and an affordable housing supply are all tightly linked to hospitals through various access points [e.g., staffing, inter-facility transfers, boarders, avoidable ED visits.]
Let’s take that one by one: Robust workforce: We don’t have one. We still have far more jobs than workers. Access to transportation: We don’t have that, nor do we have much of a plan to put one in place. An affordable housing supply: Not only do we not have it, but we are tens of thousands of homes away from such.
The reason housing was first on the list is that you can’t do much if people don’t have an affordable place to live. You will never attract people from elsewhere if they can’t find a home, hence, reaching that “robust” workforce level is a stretch.
The healthcare consultant - Dr. Bruce Hamory - released the report four months after the Legislature adjourned and thus had the benefit of digesting the Legislature’s passage of H.687, its attempt to deal with the state’s housing crisis. One could surmise he was underwhelmed with what he saw.
It’s easy to understand his concern. Mr. Hamory is working on a tight time-line. He’s made it clear that if the hospitals’ “transformation” isn’t underway in short order - like a matter of three to five years - the healthcare system could be on the verge of bankruptcy. The bill passed by the Legislature won’t even have its rule-making process complete by then.
So our fast-track healthcare crisis is being matched against a slow-track housing bill, which will never produce housing at the rate necessary to solve any need.
The question is whether legislators will recognize their error and begin again, or allow the law to remain as is, pretending that it is everything Vermonters wanted or the markets need.
Gov. Phil Scott made his displeasure with the bill known, which is why he vetoed it. Simply put, the bill creates more barriers to growth than it eliminates. It does not acknowledge the need to build large developments, preferring developments below 50-75 homes. The bill opts for development within the city’s growth district, preferring to make growth more dense. The bill also greatly expands the reach of Act 250 the state’s land use planning law.
The so-called “compromise” was between developers and environmentalists, when, in fact, the environmentalists held all the cards. The developers made a little progress. But the state, i.e., the taxpayers, the business community, our schools, our hospitals, etc., all lost. Big time.
That loss should be more obvious through the healthcare consultant’s report. The more dire the housing, the more dire the healthcare industry’s prospects. The same is true with our schools and the state’s educational system. Adequate housing is the cornerstone of a strong economy; it gives ballast to those who will provide tomorrow’s jobs.
But that’s not the housing bill passed by the Legislature. We needed a law with strength and vision and we got a law that was weak and backward looking. It’s put us at risk, as the consultant’s report makes clear.
It would be a mark of strength if the Legislature would recognize its mistakes and work to correct them when the session begins in January. If not, that, too, sends a message to the healthcare community. As the verse goes: pride goeth before destruction.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here