House Special Committee on Impeachment Inquiry forgoes recommendation; Report closes investigation into Grismore

Posted

MONTPELIER — The House Special Committee on Impeachment Inquiry – created to examine potential misuse of two Franklin County offices – released its final recommendation Tuesday to forgo filing articles of impeachment against Franklin County Sheriff John Grismore.

The final 44-page report detailing the committee’s decision examines five potential grounds for impeachment reviewed by committee members since the House established the group back in May 2023.

The conclusion reached, however, was that none of the instances rose to the level of impeachment, as the most compelling evidence was created prior to Grismore’s election as sheriff.

“Overturning an election is such a big thing,” State Rep. Mike McCarthy (D-St. Albans City), vice chair of the committee, said. “Unless the conduct occurred while the person was in office and is a deep violation of the public trust, we couldn’t see ourselves going through with the impeachment process.”

The report, however, joins a chorus of state officials calling for Grismore to resign as the committee “believes …Grismore is doing Franklin County a disservice by remaining in office.”

“In response to the Special Committee's Final Report, I am both pleased and disappointed,” Grismore said by email. “I'm pleased that the voters of Franklin County, who have demonstrated their faith in me both at the polls and in personal comments of support, have been vindicated.  As a life-long Vermonter, I am terribly disappointed in the amount of time and money that has been wasted on this process.” 

Final recommendation

The wide-ranging report released by the special committee on Monday covers much of the publicly-available information that has been reported around Sheriff John Grismore’s case since the state began exploring reports of maladministration.

Grismore first made headlines in August 2022 after a video of him striking a man in custody went viral, shaking up his campaign for Franklin County Sheriff. In the subsequent years, Grismore won the seat for sheriff, but he also faced reports of potential financial irregularities as well as underwent decertification of his law enforcement license over a year after the use-of-force incident.

Despite the challenges, Grismore has defended his past actions, and he’s remained in office with few complaints heard from Franklin County residents. 

Grismore said the office recently signed a 40-hour a week contract with Highgate, and the office is exploring contracts with Franklin County towns seeking expanded law enforcement services as concerns about Vermont’s drug trade increase.

“We have recently hired a new, full-time deputy and have several others in the hire process,” Grismore said. “We continue to move this office forward despite the many political distractions.”

The special committee on impeachment inquiry, however, has been exploring how Grismore’s actions intersected with potential grounds for impeachment for close to a year. Essentially, Vermont’s state constitution has no legal definition for what constitutes an impeachable offense, leaving the General Assembly to make the determination, and the report covers how legislators on the special committee sought out additional info on various impeachment processes in order to identify what constituted potential maladministration of the office.

The committee eventually settled on five potential grounds for impeachment. They were Grismore’s past use-of-force, the limitations put on the sheriff’s office due to Grismore’s law enforcement decertification, the sheriff’s office’s current operations under Grismore and two instances of faulty books before Grismore headed the office. 

Examinations of each case, however, ended up failing to meet the impeachment standards.

For three of the five cases, Grismore’s actions took place before he was elected sheriff, and the remaining two areas of investigation – decertification and the office’s current operations – didn’t rise to the level necessary for impeachment. 

The report’s final conclusion, however, doesn’t clear Grismore’s name. After a year of looking into the office, the special committee pushed forward an official House resolution calling on Grismore to vacate the role of sheriff, as he’s “doing Franklin County a disservice by remaining in office.” 

“​​First, the Committee believes it is important for a Sheriff to be able to fulfill law enforcement duties, not simply administrative ones. Second, to effectively manage a staff of deputies exercising law enforcement duties, a Sheriff should receive ongoing law enforcement training, which is unavailable to a decertified officer. Third, a Sheriff should demonstrate and uphold the highest standards of honesty, integrity, conduct, and service. Through his conduct prior to taking office and his continued insistence that his use of force was appropriate, Mr. Grismore demonstrates none of these,” the report reads.

While the special committee can now close its book on impeachment, Grismore will still likely feel some impacts from state regulations on sheriffs if the General Assembly moves forward with expanded efforts to put more guardrails in place for county officeholders.

As McCarthy explained, the impeachment committee found that sheriffs and states’ attorneys have roles largely defined by the state constitution, and McCarthy has been pushing legislation forward to better define the pay-rates and overall operations of county offices. Included in H. 585,  for example, is a 30% adjustment to what the state would pay sheriffs with no law enforcement certification – a situation uniquely held by Grismore.

“Impeachment is just a serious removal of an elected official; we need to make sure that’s not the only tool to limit the power of an elected law enforcement officer,” McCarthy said.

Without his police certification, McCarthy said Grismore can’t move forward with many important parts of the job, such as transporting prisoners, going on patrol, carrying a sidearm or arresting people, and the state already has delineated different pay rates depending on what level of certification an officer holds.

There are also questions about funds located by the special impeachment inquiry related to the sheriff’s office. While examining retirement funds at the office, the committee found evidence roughly $20,000 had likely been misappropriated, and McCarthy agreed to work with fellow committee member Rep. Carolyn Branagan (R-Georgia) to identify what needs to be done to make the books whole.

And when the next election for sheriff comes around, McCarthy said Franklin County residents will get to see the committee’s work examining Grismore’s record before going to the polls.

“I think that we’ve uncovered an enormous amount of information on how the Franklin County Sheriff’s Office operates. We made it really clear that impeachment on its own was not a remedy of the challenges we had in the offices of Franklin County,” McCarthy said. “Now, we have a record that the public can look at.” 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here