Hospitals need help that only GMCB can provide

Posted

The hospital in Brattleboro is on pace to lose $14 million this year and has lost an estimated $30 million over the last two fiscal years. The hospital has shuttered its birthing center to help cut costs. The hospital’s circumstances are so dire that the town selectboard considered the idea of raising local taxes to help.

The selectboard’s beneficence didn’t last. Taxpayers thought little of the idea, and even the hospital didn’t want the division the million-dollar tax increase would invite.

The hospital has requested a grant under the Rural Health Transformation Program to help make ends meet. The state has received $195 million from the feds and will receive $195 million each year for the next five years.

But, as we understand the grant, the money is not to be used to fill budget holes; it’s meant to be part of a collective effort to change the way Vermont delivers health care - hopefully in a cheaper way and with improved access and quality.

Brattleboro’s circumstances are instructive. All of Vermont’s hospitals are under severe budget pressures. Our small hospitals in particular. Yet, their plight goes unnoticed in the main. Taxpayers in Brattleboro weren’t interested in paying more out of their pockets to help keep the hospital’s doors open. So the hospital lost its birthing center, which isn’t much of a recipe for future growth in Brattleboro and its service area. 

These budget pressures were anticipated by the Oliver Wyman study commissioned by the Green Mountain Care Board in 2024. The authors of the report made note of the fact that if the state’s hospitals weren’t “reorganized,” Vermont could expect that some hospitals would have no choice but to close their doors. The report said 13 of the state’s 14 hospitals would be operating in the red by 2028. It was a call for a wholesale change in how our health care system functions. 

We are galloping closer and closer to that reality.

Which invites the question: Who is in charge? Who has the responsibility, or authority, to tell hospitals what services they can provide and at what cost? Who protects the integrity of the system writ large?

It’s not the hospitals. It’s not the individual communities affected. It’s not the state, or the Legislature. Each group is naturally positioned to protect what exists. It’s self-interest at its purest. It isn’t, for example, Northwestern Medical Center’s job to do what’s best for Brattleboro. Its job is to serve the Franklin County market, which is tough enough.

So who is the planner? Who is the adversary, the one who lays down the law? Whose responsibility is it to keep the doors open, but to do so in a way that lowers costs?

That’s the debate we should be having. No one is leaping up anxious to deal with what is probably the state’s most complicated challenge. Politically, it’s a non-starter. It’s an assured way of making more people unhappy than happy. 

No hospital wants to be told to change, or to do with less. 

The obvious “leadership” choice should be the Green Mountain Care Board. The five members are appointed for six-year terms, which shields them from political repercussions. They have a deep understanding of the issues and know the players. 

It’s not crystal clear that the board has complete authority. And it’s a given that some people think the board’s power should be lessened, not increased.

That would be a mistake of egregious proportions. Vermont would end up in a battle of self-interest with taxpayers and patients being the losers. 

It should be made clear that the GMCB has the authority it needs not only to set the hospitals’ budgets but to help them carve out their respective services so that duplication is avoided and the downward pressure on prices continues. That clarity should be provided by the governor, the state’s Auditor and the Legislature.

Most important, it’s also the responsibility of the GMCB to keep the hospitals’ doors open. That is difficult to do if the only power the GMCB exercises is giving hospitals a thumbs-up or a thumbs-down on its budget.

Vermont’s hospitals present their budgets to the GMCB in August, and the board will give its guidance by the end of September. Vermonters can expect a troubling picture from our hospitals; what we need to hear is that the board has a plan to reconfigure the state’s health care system in a way that keeps our hospitals viable and our costs lower. 

By Emerson Lynn

   

   

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here