Hospital budgets are in, the debate continues

Posted

This week, Vermont’s hospitals will submit their proposed budgets for the next fiscal year to the Green Mountain Care Board. It’s likely the budgets will be red-stained. Northwestern Medical Center’s budget, for example, will reportedly be $4.4 million in the red, putting the hospital in the position of asking the Green Mountain Care Board, the state’s health care regulator, for guidance.

NMC’s budget deficit is likely to be a pittance compared to what is expected from the University of Vermont Medical Center, which has been told it needs to cut $300 million from its budget over the next three years.

The central question is whether Vermont’s healthcare system can provide access to quality care while creating and then implementing the substantial structural changes needed to reduce our healthcare costs. 

We won’t know the answer to that for several years. It’s a monstrously complicated process that affects every Vermonter. It represents 20 percent of the state’s gross domestic product. But an affordable, quality-driven healthcare system is essential for the state to meet any of its growth targets.

As has been said loud and clear, our options are limited. Our health care costs are higher here than in any other state. The status quo is not an option.Going back is not an option.

There is a smidgen of good news. The health care community - writ large - isn’t sitting idly by. UVMMC, for example, recently announced layoffs of roughly 150 people. This week it announced more cuts would be made. In addition, the hospital is telling its doctors to see more patients [UVMMC’s doctors are at the 25th percentile nationally in terms of the number of patients seen]. The hospital also eliminated bonuses for its executives.

This has happened, in large part, because the Green Mountain Care Board is doing its job, which is forcing hospitals to look at their budgets more critically and creatively. There is no way to make healthcare more affordable in Vermont if the hospitals’ budgets aren’t regulated. There are other actors involved as well. The Agency of Human Resources is involved, as is the Vermont Department of Financial Regulation. There is the “liaison team” led by Mike Smith, former head of the Agency of Human Services. There is the Federal Rural Health Transformation Program, which might bring $195 million to Vermont each year for the next five years.

VHC911, a health care group of interested citizens, headed by former Gov. Jim Douglas and former head of the Vermont Business Roundtable, Lisa Ventriss, this month released a summary of eight separate “transformation initiatives” that are underway:

• Hospital optimization and efficiency.

• Regionalization of services

• Primary care [Blueprint modernization]

• Expansion of community-based services

• Technology advancements

• Advanced analytics and modeling

• Reference-based pricing

•Rural health transformation program

The vast majority of us know little or nothing about any of these efforts. We see the headlines, little else. It makes it easy to blame others for a hospital’s circumstances. It’s probably easiest to blame the GMCB because it’s the group responsible for voting up or down on a hospital’s budget.

If they didn’t do it, who would?

The challenge is that there is a lot of self-interest involved. Each hospital wants to protect what it has. It’s uncomfortable to talk about ways to collaborate if that collaboration pushes a hospital to send its patients elsewhere. No hospital wants to do with less. That’s why we have put in place a system that, theoretically, overrides self-interest, one that works for the collective good. That’s the goal.

Unfortunately, most of this effort is being done behind closed doors, which makes it easier to find a bad guy to blame. Vermonters need to be told what is happening. They need to be part of the conversation. And we need our elected leaders to guide this conversation honestly and with the patience necessary to allow the process to work.

It’s hard stuff. And we will make mistakes that will force us to try other options. What’s not acceptable? Retreat. Giving up. Looking to past practices for answers. Succumbing to the far left politicos who still hang on to the dream of a single payer system. 

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here