For the second week, we have reprinted letters from supporters of the hospitals in Randolph and Newport articulating the same fear: Their hospitals have been targeted by a healthcare consultant as places that need to be closed or reconfigured. The authors make the same argument: Close down our hospitals and you close down our towns.
The consultant - Dr. Bruce Hamory, of Oliver Wyman consultancy - put together a 144-page report on Vermont’s hospitals, something mandated by statute. The bottom-line message was that all hospitals in Vermont are in jeopardy and that if the system is not “transformed” within three years many of our hospitals will be forced to close.
“Every prediction I can make, with every trick I know to pull, says that within three to five years, your back will call the bill and close you,” Mr. Hamory said.
It’s not just the hospitals in Randolph and Newport that have been targeted for closure- or radical transformation - but Grace Cottage in Townshend and Springfield. The reaction from each of the communities is similar. Closure is not an option. Pick on someone else.
The reaction goes beyond those four communities. UVM Medical Center recently said it would put construction of its newly approved surgical center off for at least a year. The hospital also said it would be forced to reduce its services. The hospital blamed the Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB]. The hospital had petitioned the state's regulator for a rate increase of 6.8 percent. Instead, the GMCB told the hospital to cut its rates by one percent. Collectively, Vermont’s hospitals had asked for a 5.7 percent increase. The GMCB responded with a 3.4 percent increase.
In other words, the pain extends through Vermont’s 14 hospitals. All are affected, some more than others. How the challenge is met - or isn’t - will be one of the state’s defining efforts in the next three to five years.
We have two choices: First, do nothing. Be entirely on the defensive. Rely on local politicians to discredit the consultant’s [and the GMCB’s] warning. Continue to accept double-digit increases in healthcare premiums.
Or, second, accept the challenge and, as a state, put together a strategy that explores different options, with the intent to keep the healthcare system strong but affordable.
It may be that we can’t afford 14 hospitals as now configured. But closing down a hospital should also require a herculean effort to help build up the community in different ways. For example, why not replicate St. Albans’ TIF district concept in a targeted way to help these communities grow in more sustainable ways? St. Albans City has increased its grand list by close to $100 million. Could that not happen in Springfield, or Newport, or other Vermont towns?
We have the time to respond with the degree of prudence necessary. The Green Mountain Care Board is not about to force any hospital to shut its doors. Its fondest wish is to see the sorts of changes necessary to keep all the state’s hospitals open and affordable. But to get from here to there will require all participants to shoulder their share of the tasks ahead.
What’s inescapable is the need for a healthcare system that’s affordable to Vermonters. It was not long ago that Vermont was ranked 43rd in its healthcare costs, today we are in the top ten, and climbing. That’s not something that attracts newcomers to our state. It’s not something that keeps people here.
It’s also an enormously complicated issue and one that is politically divisive. Healthcare constitutes 20 percent of the state’s economy and communities are understandably defensive about keeping what they have. But that’s a status quo posture, which we cannot afford. It would be tragic to wake up a short three to five years from now to see the demise of our rural hospitals knowing that, as a state, we did nothing to address today’s troubled trajectory.
Vermont’s hospitals would need roughly $3 billion in subsidies over the next five years to remain solvent with today’s operations in place, according to Mr. Hamory’s research. That’s beyond Vermont’s reach, particularly when other issues are factored in, such as property tax increases and the need for housing.
There are ways to address all issues, but what we must be leery of above all things is to be divided on the issue. This is not about Newport, Randolph, Springfield, or Gifford Hospital. It’s not all about UVM Medical Center and its need to cut costs. It’s about the state’s health care system writ large and how it can be reconfigured to provide quality care affordably. It’s about figuring out how best to match a community’s needs with new options.
We can’t wish this challenge away. If ever there was a call for leadership. This is it. We're waiting.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here