Guest editorial: What connects us in Franklin County? Our shared values

Posted

Recently, I was asked, “Where are you from?”  My reply: Franklin County and rural places.

If asking where you’re from is a question about where you’re at home, my local is rural. For me, it’s where I grew up, the town I came back to, the town I live in and the towns in which I work, visit, and recreate. It’s Franklin County and rural places that I keep coming home to.

I think of Franklin County as rural, though by some measures it’s not. 

What is rural? No one definition exists. We understand it along a spectrum: how close to a population density and nearness of urban settings. The U.S. Census Bureau finds that one in five Americans live in rural places. In 2021, the U.S. Dept. of Health and Human Service’s Health Research Services Administration (HRSA), found that in Vermont more than 60% of us are rural. The U.S. Office of Management and Budget adds to its definition of rural the consideration of labor markets, making Franklin County “metropolitan” by measure. 

Rural is also a cultural concept.  It’s a set of ideas that culminate around agriculture, natural amenities, and tight-knit communities with regional differences. In Franklin County, rural is often bound to the shared knowledge that it’s special, unique as both a physical place and something more. 

More than 90% of our country’s land mass is considered rural.  Rural accounts for vital natural resources -- crucial sources of water, food, energy and recreation for the entirety of the U.S. It’s not a stretch to see that the health and well-being of our rural places are linked to our health as a State and nation.

Possibly that’s why the dominant narrative that there is a fractious cultural divide between rural and urban feels increasingly uncomfortable. It’s an account that casts rural as a condition to overcome or a place to make a final stand. 

Whether it’s true, it certainly is no wonder. 

Despite the knowledge we’re vital, the news suggests that if it were a contest between rural and urban America – even rural and urban Vermont --  the game is rigged. In rural places, we face worse health outcomes and, shockingly, a “mortality penalty.” The gap between rural and urban mortality rates crew by 75% between 2004 in 2016. (Growth and Persistence of Place-Based Mortality in the United States, A. Cosby, Am J. Public Health, (Jan. 2019)). Data from the USDA over the last 30 years shows that poverty is persistently higher in rural places and student outcomes are lower. The Population Health Institute’s 2023 Health Ranking Report shows that Franklin County, when compared to Vermont at large, has fewer primary health care providers per capita, higher unemployment, and longer commute times. Women in Franklin and Grand Isle Counties continue to earn less than males for the same job and housing is in short supply. The availability of childcare? …don’t get me started.

The broad-brush strokes of these statistics fail to tell the whole story. Franklin County has lower income inequality, a growing food economy, and substantial natural amenities anchored by remarkable soil quality, deciduous forests, and Lake Champlain. And by my own metric, a share of the most beautiful places in Vermont. 

Deliberating the various classifications of “rural” matters. The classification of rural can shape communities’ eligibility for federal and state resources. Access to resources is necessary for building meaningful community infrastructure. Community infrastructure -- health care facilities, high speed internet, good roads and clean water –are what shape the well-being of our rural health and begin to right inequities.

Arbitrary delineations limit access and close down opportunity. It’s worth thinking  about how mischaracterization also poorly serves when it comes to the storyline of a cultural divide between rural and urban. Assumptions that this division is simply about envy or self-righteousness overlooks the possibility of a more complicated truth. It may have something to do with the chaffing that occurs when we make presumptions about others. 

One way out is noticing that rural America is not homogenous. Franklin County is no monolith and doesn’t fit or belong under a neat, single heading. Treating it that way falls back on the stereotypes that rural is something to romanticize or distain. 

What distinguishes us isn’t how far we are from Chittenden County. What distinguishes us is our ability to be resourceful, curious and creative. Rural makes us a county of doers, makers, artists and innovators because we know that one size does not fit all. The solutions that may work for Morrisville, Bristol or Cabot, may not be what works for Fairfax, Sheldon or Berkshire. We need each other to get by in rural places and we rely upon the differences among us to keep us strong and thriving.

What connects us in Franklin County are our shared values of independence, common sense, tradition, frugality, community, and hard work. These shared values are what help us recognize we’re individuals and we’re a community. It’s why it’s worth driving down our backroads. And it’s why it’s worth talking with our neighbors even when we’re not sure we’ll agree. 

–Vanessa Kittell

Born and raised in Franklin County, Kittell is a trial lawyer with her own practice in St. Albans. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here