I believe Act 250 is overdue for transformation. Act 250 has done its job and I appreciate the role it has played in protecting Vermont’s most cherished assets. But I also believe that change is overdue. Let’s rely on local and regional planning to do more of the work.
Act 250 was passed in 1970, and came of age during the high growth times of the 1980s and 1990s. During that time, Franklin County grew by almost 15% each decade and Grand Isle County grew by 30% in the 1990s alone. Employment grew at an even faster rate – over 30% each decade. Statewide, schools were at capacity, local governments were concerned about municipal services and tax rates. Local planning and zoning were relatively new and local volunteers were challenged to manage the high levels of growth.
People were scared about rapid change and what it meant for their communities and the state. As a planner working in our communities, I shared those concerns, and helped to write local regulations that limited growth to a manageable level. Act 250 served an important role – a check on larger developments to ensure they did not overwhelm our communities or change Vermont into something unrecognizable.
Times have changed. In the past decade population, growth in our region fell to about 5%, statewide it was less than 3%. We have a shortage of workers. We have a shortage of housing. And we cannot solve one without the other. Many communities have robust local planning and strong development regulations; they are prepared to manage growth in ways that respect the resources that make Vermont special.
Vermont can do more to encourage growth in and near our downtowns and villages. When development happens in areas that have infrastructure and capacity to accommodate growth, it is less costly to provide services, such as transit, parks and sidewalks. It allows for vibrant economic development, improved social connections, and maximizes the return on public investment in infrastructure. One way to encourage the growth we need, where we want it, is to eliminate unnecessary regulations.
That is where Act 250 transformation comes in. When planned growth areas also have strong local development regulations, there is no need to have the extra cost, time and duplication of Act 250 review. Local and regional planning can be trusted to identify growth areas, and communities can be trusted to manage the growth in those places. This is a simple concept, but untangling decades of regulation and permits is a complicated task that raises a long list of important questions.
Three legislatively directed study committees are trying to answer these questions. Vermont’s Regional Planning Commissions were asked to provide recommendations on how we can complete consistent plans for the future, including mapping planned growth areas. The Natural Resources Board, a body that oversees Act 250, is examining how to adjust Act 250 based on location- encouraging development in designated areas while maintaining rural working lands, and protecting natural resources. And, the Agency of Commerce and Community Development is developing recommendations to modernize and simplify its programs that provide incentives and regulatory relief to designated areas within communities.
These studies are all moving toward a related set of recommendations that, if enacted, would make significant changes to how Act 250 is applied in our communities. In short, strong local planning and investment, in planned growth areas, would be rewarded by Act 250 exemption.
Act 250 reform has been proposed and debated nearly every year since it was enacted. In my conversations with legislators, developers, local and state officials and environmental leaders, I’ve heard a growing consensus. It is time to let local and regional planning take the reins in our planned growth areas, and leave Act 250 in place elsewhere to protect our treasured environmental resources.
We still need Act 250. But I believe it is time to use Act 250 in a different way, a way that meets the needs of now, and the needs of our future Vermont.
–Catherine Dimitruk, Northwest Regional Planning Commission executive director
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here