Gov's universal school choice idea upends education in Vermont

Posted

When this year’s debate over Vermont’s educational system began, there was a collective call for fresh thinking about an issue where all the answers had been tried and failed. That call for a new start came from Gov. Phil Scott and was blessed by the Legislature’s Democratic leadership. Both sides agreed that what was in place was too expensive and that the decline in school testing was unacceptable.

It was an opening Mr. Scott moved quickly to fill, albeit in bits and pieces, without the connective tissue necessary to understand how the final form would function and to what effect.

The governor's first proposal was to consolidate the state’s 119 school districts into five regional districts and to shift from the current funding system to a foundation formula.

That alone would have been sufficient in terms of occupying the Legislature for the remainder of the session, but late last week, Education Secretary Zoie Saunders testified before the House Education Committee, where she unveiled the administration’s plan to allow all Vermont’s 75,000 students the chance to attend the school of their choice.

That was a shock to most Vermonters. In almost every respect, the governor’s proposal upends education in Vermont as we know it. To say it’s a heavy lift is a massive understatement. Democrats may have lost their veto-proof majorities in November’s election, but they still have strong majorities. As much as they would like the cost of education to disappear from their list of concerns, they are not likely to flip to a school-choice state.

But in politics, every proposal has to be viewed as an entry point to negotiations. The Scott administration will plead its case. They will argue that the foundation formula makes understanding how we pay for our schools clearer and how it offers a tool to keep costs manageable. They will argue that the move to five regional school districts reduces costs and gives the leadership an opportunity to improve educational outcomes. They will argue that school choice offers parents a better match with their students’ needs.

We are at the leading edge of what may be one of the most important debates in recent memory. Vermont’s educational system is in tatters and needs immediate tending. What the Democrats need to avoid is following the opposition down the rabbit hole, declaring there is no room for compromise.

There is. Switching from our existing funding system to a foundation plan that meets the requirements of the Supreme Court's Brigham decision is imminently doable. Consolidating 119 school districts into five regional districts is too much, but taking the existing 52 supervisory unions and cutting them into, say, half would do a better job of representing districts’ needs. It also imposes a governance structure necessary to deal with the more pivotal educational and cost issues.

The universal school choice proposal is not politically tenable, at least with the tiny bit of information that has been released by the Agency of Education or the Scott administration. But a fuller debate of the proposal may be enough to push the Democrats into considering their alternatives.

Here is the bottom line: The only way to successfully address the cost of education and academic outcomes is by insisting on a certain class and school size. We have too many small schools. Closing them is not something the governor is willing to do. Or the Legislature. Shutting down a school is beyond the political appetite of either. It is something, however, that a regional school board could do, something the Agency of Education could insist on by putting in place “clear education quality and financial metrics,” as Ms. Saunders testified.

There is yet another “tool” for the newly created school districts to aid in their decision-making: school construction money. To catch up with the deferred maintenance needs of our schools will require an estimated six billion dollars, according to a state report. Of that $6 billion, $250,000,000 was needed this school year. Obviously, if any school needing construction money also fell into the category of being too small to defend keeping open, that would reduce costs. 

The debate has begun, although the administration is months late in providing the necessary detail required to have a full understanding of what is being pitched and the details that support the direction. But as with any debate of import, it’s crucial to follow the words of Otto von Bismarck: “Politics is the art of the possible, the attainable - the art of the next best.”

"Next best" may still be an essential step forward for Vermont's educational system.

By Emerson Lynn

#sanl

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here