Gov's ed proposal the bold plan Legislature needed

Posted

Vermont legislators have gotten what they asked for, which is for the governor to step away from the safety of the bleachers and offer some “bold” leadership on issues that challenge Vermont’s prosperity, chief among them a new vision for the state’s educational system.

Last Wednesday Vermont Education Secretary Zoie Saunders unveiled the governor’s plan, the major items being a consolidation of the state’s 52 supervisory unions into five regional districts, a change from the existing funding system to a foundation formula, and the shift in rule-making authority from the State Board of Education to the Agency of Education. There was also a hint the proposal would include stronger rules governing the size of classrooms and schools, which would include graduation requirements, the quality of education offered, and the cost of our smaller schools.

Had the governor’s proposal been offered a year ago it would have been torn to shreds. Too bold, too much change, too many unknowns. Politically, it would have been child’s play to spin the proposal into something that would threaten what we had. 

Today, the governor’s proposal is being given serious consideration with the Legislature’s Democratic leadership thanking the governor for his efforts and leadership. That’s the power of a November election that cost the Democrats more seats than anywhere else in the nation.

Democrats are now fully aware of the need to find their own way to the front of the affordability crowd. They will go forward - or should - understanding that roughly three-quarters of the voters in Vermont do not have children in school and that the majority of Vermonters put affordability above all other considerations.

As the debate begins the governing objective should be one of clarity and confirmation. For example, one of the key proposals is consolidating the state’s 52 supervisory unions into five regions. All of Franklin County’s schools would be combined with those in Chittenden County. Our schools would still have representation, but they would be advisory in nature. 

Would that save money? Maybe. But not a lot. Certainly not enough to give teachers some extra cash as has been suggested. Besides that single big district would still require local direction. So while we’d have one superintendent running all the schools in both counties we’d have roughly the same number of supervisory personnel. Before this was accepted, we’d need to know how it would be set up and be able to prove the math to show the savings.

To change from the existing funding formula to the foundation plan is not difficult, once upon a time Vermont paid for its schools using the foundation formula. What matters is how much money is allocated on a per-pupil basis and if it reflects a true school choice option. [It’s difficult if not impossible to offer school choice and expect a reduction in total costs.]

The real substance of the governor’s proposal was the part that said “…schools will be assessed based on financial viability and education quality…Schools that fall short of these standards will be offered a range of options, including resource sharing or merging…” The proposal takes into account the need for minimum class size and quality of education considerations.

There it is. The only way to make education in Vermont more affordable is to reduce the number of schools and increase class sizes. It’s also a key way to improve the quality of education offered. If changing the state’s governance structure is what’s required to make those decisions, then that's part of the discussion.

The good news is that the governor has taken the first step and the breadth and depth of his proposal is on a scale Vermont has not witnessed. This offers the Legislature the opportunity to restore some of the lost luster of an educational system that used to not only be affordable but a system that was regarded as one of the nation’s best.

By Emerson Lynn

#sanl

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here