Gov stands up to Trump's lies, why not others?

Posted

It was long ago that we had elected representatives afraid to exercise their constitutional obligation to offer their "advice and consent" to the president. We are there now, given the record of Congressional Republicans and their unabashed fear to "advise" President Trump that he is in error not only with several of his cabinet choices but with the resetting of long-held relationships with other nations abroad, and our neighbors. Republicans have offered no advice, only their silent consent.

Nowhere is that more evident than in the president’s actions regarding the war in Ukraine, its president Volodymyr Zelensky, and how Mr. Trump's “negotiations” are rewriting history with Vladimir Putin’s Russia and the NATO alliance. As stark, and disruptive, as the president’s lies are, Congressional Republicans, again, remain mum.

Which makes it all the more important to bring attention to Vermont’s Republican Gov. Phil Scott who, on Monday, issued a press release acknowledging that it was three years ago to the day that Russia invaded Ukraine.

“On February 24, 2022, Russian military forces crossed the eastern border of Ukraine. Russia’s unprovoked aggression escalated a years-long conflict into outright war, threatening the sovereignty of a free nation, and the hard-won peace of the European continent. These are facts, and it’s important to repeat them when the truth is threatened. Three years later Vermonters still stand with Ukraine. We still hope for peace and a just end to this senseless war. We still hold fast to the most American of ideals: liberty, self-determination and the restoration, preservation, and expansion of freedom around the world.”

-Gov. Phil Scott

Mr. Scott’s aversion to Mr. Trump has a long history. He was opposed to Mr. Trump from the moment he announced his intentions to run for president in 2016. He did not support him in his 2024 bid. He believes the president’s character is not suitable for the task. [Which is an understatement.] He does not pick fights with the president, but, when necessary, makes his opposition known. He's one of the very few.

That used to be the role of moderate conservatives, once known as “Wednesday Club Republicans”, who also had the reputation of getting things done. Their ranks have disappeared.

The starkness between Republicans past and today’s Republican Party is clearest [and most frightening] with the nation’s foreign policy and its post-World War II allies. It’s stunning to have the new president of Germany, Friedrich Merz address the world saying “It’s clear that the Americans, at least this American administration, are largely indifferent to the fate of Europe” and that Europe would have to strengthen itself “as fast as possible so that we gradually achieve independence from the U.S.”

Wow. How is it that with the snap of a single election, and one only narrowly won by Mr. Trump, we have gone from a nation whose historic allies have put trust at the center of our relationships, to a nation that can’t be trusted, to a nationrepresented by a president to whom all relationships are purely transactional?

How do we remain silent when Mr. Trump lies to us and to the world about how the war began [Ukraine started it, not Russia] and what Ukraine needs to pay us for services rendered [$500 billion and counting?] How do we expect our allies to respond when our president sends a clear message that their problems are of no concern to us?

Trust is established over time. It can be lost in a moment. Any leader with an understanding of history and a grounding in grace understands that at some point you will always need your friends. That’s particularly true when the world’s political landscape is as problematic as it is today. Not only is the world changing technologically, but the inexorable rise of China and the thirst of Putin to restore Russia to its Soviet Union borders, are absolutes that can’t be ignored, or bought off.

How we conduct ourselves among old friends now will determine how those friends respond to us when the time comes. If we say “you are on your own” today, they are justified in saying the same to us later. And there is always a later.

That has to be obvious to us all. But that’s not enough. Republicans who know better have to find their voices. They need to shed the fear of Mr. Trump's wrath understanding that truth is what prevails against today’s authoritarian winds. As Mr. Scott has shown, “advice and consent” should not be something exercised alone by the opposition party, in fact, it’s most important coming from those closest to you.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here