Gov should give Legislature a single task

Posted

Vermont’s lieutenant governor-elect John Rodgers has joined a chorus of lawmakers, medical staff, and community protestors opposed to cuts in service proposed by the UVM Health Network. Mr. Rodgers questions the hospital’s choice in how it should respond to the Green Mountain Care Board’s order for the hospital to cut what it can charge commercial insurance by one percent. The in-between-the-lines question is why a two-billion-dollar-a-year operation felt obliged to cut essential services rather than cinch in its belt as urged by the state’s regulator.

The question is one likely to end up in the Legislature’s lap, along with the need to rethink how we pay for our schools. Both issues are framed by the same two concerns; how to maintain the quality of the services and do so at an affordable cost. Both also suffer from the same reality: their systems are dense and difficult to understand, which is why, as a state, we’ve deferred any serious effort to rethink how they operate.

The time for inaction has passed. The Oliver Wyman study of our hospitals predicts the system is headed toward bankruptcy if nothing changes. The study of Vermont's schools conducted by Picus Odden & Associates shows we could spend $400 million to $460 million less and get better outcomes if we adopted policy changes, including consolidation.

There are no two issues that matter more to the state. Good schools and good health care are what attract families to Vermont. Good schools and good health care at affordable prices are what keep Vermonters here.

These are not issues that can be resolved outside the legislative process, as history shows. The fact that the Democrats lost their super-majorities in both houses restores the political balance necessary to consider ideas that have heretofore been dismissed. The objective with both our schools and our hospitals is to figure out how to make things work and to cap costs at an affordable price.

On Monday, the Vermont Department of Taxes issued its “Dec. 1, letter” with its prediction that next year’s property taxes would jump another 5.9 percent, which means that over the last three years, Vermonters will have paid 33 percent more in property taxes. Vermonters also pay the highest health insurance premiums in the country and double the national average. One issue folds into the other: health care costs for teachers will increase 12 percent, a key factor in rising school budgets.

In other words, the task ahead is to make both healthcare and education the Legislature’s single focus. Gov. Phil Scott should rip a page from Gov. Peter Shumlin’s decision in 2014 to devote his entire State of the State message to drug addiction. Mr. Scott should do the same with education and healthcare. Both are in crisis. Both are essential. And the cost of both is out of control.

The governor should lay out his vision and ask that the Legislature make it its priority. All other issues should be of secondary importance. We’ve kicked these cans down the road for years and look where it’s left us. As the voters made clear in November’s general election, past practices didn’t work and they are watching to see if things change.

By Emerson Lynn  

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here