Gov right to take on Trump. Sanders overshoots

Posted

Gov. Phil Scott was right to call out President Trump for his siege of Minneapolis and the wrongful death of Alex Pretti, a 37-year-old nurse, saying Mr. Trump “should pause these operations, de-escalate the situation, and reset the federal government’s focus on truly criminal illegal immigrants.”

Spot on.

It’s critical that the president hears from party leaders concerned about the nation’s direction and who dare to challenge the president’s leadership. As is painfully obvious, they are few in number.

The governor’s words reflect what most mainstream Americans feel: “At best, these federal immigration operations are a complete failure of coordination of acceptable public safety and law enforcement practices, training, and leadership. At worst, it’s a deliberate federal intimidation and incitement of American citizens that’s resulting in the murder of Americans. Again, enough is enough.”

Mr. Pretti’s death is the second in Minneapolis, Renee Good being the first, and the political fallout for the administration is being seen as the president’s largest test to date. It doesn’t help that the president’s senior staff - Stephen Miller, the deputy chief of staff, and Kristi Noem, the homeland security secretary - began spreading false accusations against both victims before any information was publicly available.

Mr. Pretti was immediately termed a “domestic terrorist” before anyone knew his name. He was said to be “brandishing” a gun. He was not. It was his phone. One would think such errors of judgment should be grounds for dismissal.

But what should we expect? If the troops running the president’s mass deportation campaign are told they enjoy complete immunity from anything they might do “in the line of duty,” why are we surprised that innocent people are killed?

The president is becoming aware of his vulnerability, which is why he has tried to mend fences with Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz - heretofore someone he disparaged at every opportunity. The president’s poll numbers are in the tank, and Americans are questioning whether they are safer or less safe with the president’s deportation efforts. The mid-term elections are nine months away, and Republicans now face an uphill battle to retain their majority in the House.

Whereas Mr. Scott has responded in a way that comports with most Americans, Sen. Bernie Sanders has taken his response up a notch or two. Shocker.

Vermont’s senior senator wants an end to qualified immunity and for all ICE and U.S. Customs and Border Protection [CBP] to be unmasked, an end to detentions and deportations of U.S. Citizens, and no more stopping people based on race or the language they speak. And he wants “Trump’s domestic army out of Minnesota and Maine NOW.”

That’s defensible, but he then adds the need to “repeal the $75 billion for ICE and the nearly $65 billion for CBP in Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill and restore funding to health care.”

In other words, he wants the organizations defunded, and he’s willing to shut down the government - again - to get it done. The DHS spending bill has to be approved by Friday.

This is exactly the wrong thing to do. Mr. Sanders is pushing his party to make the same mistake it made with its “defund the police” campaign, which many argue cost the Democrats the 2024 election.

The mistake of the Biden administration was failing to understand the need for a secure border. People want to feel safe, and they want the criminals deported. The last thing Democrats should do is to give the public safety argument back to the president. They can demand a process that is bound by laws and accountability. They can make it clear that federal immigration offices cannot act with impunity. The troops should be forced to unmask themselves and to wear body cameras. But Mr. Sanders and his Democratic brethren would be foolish to advocate tearing the whole house down by defunding ICE and CBP.

For the Trump administration, this is a turning point. It is confronting the biggest political and moral challenge to its agenda, and Vermont’s governor has pointed the way forward.

Mr. Sanders et all should not waste their ammunition by firing in the wrong direction.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here