Gov, Phil Scott devoted the entirety of his State of the State address to a single topic: education. On the Legislature’s opening day, Senate President Pro Tem Phil Baruth did the same in his address The governor outlined the reasons why the state could not avoid its responsibilities for building a leaner, less costly, and more equitable school system. Mr. Baruth confined his concern to the property tax and said he would introduce a bill to force schools to cap their budgets for fiscal years 2028-2029.
There is a political element behind the aims of both. The governor understands the potency of the tax department’s prediction of a 12 percent increase in property taxes, and he laid the responsibility in the Legislature’s lap. Mr. Baruth’s mission was to counter with a tax-reducing measure of his own. He needs to find a shield for his Democratic brethren to avoid a repeat of the 2024 bloodbath [on the same issue] that cost the Democrats their legislative supermajority.
It’s a continuation/escalation of the affordability debate that has shaped Vermont’s political alignment for the last decade.
Mr. Scott makes the point that the state has increased its spending on Vermont’s schools from $1.6 billion when he first took office in 2017 to $2.5 billion this year. The increases came even though our schools are educating 30,000 fewer students than they were a generation ago. Additionally, our students’ test scores have dropped from the top 10 percent nationally to the bottom third.
There isn’t enough lipstick to make that pig kissable.
Mr. Baruth’s “allowable cap” bill is largely for show and would not apply to this year’s school budgets. The governor has proposed taking $75 million from the general fund to lessen the impact of the projected property tax increase. The problem with both approaches is that neither addresses the impetus behind what causes school spending to rise. And, we have no “extra” money this year. Using $75 million to soften the blow of a property tax increase just kicks the can down the road and takes money from other needs. Forcing schools to operate under a funding cap just gives schools less flexibility in how they operate.
Mr. Scott made it clear he thinks the reform of our school system is the state’s top priority. He said, “I will not sign a budget or an education bill or tax bill that deviates from Act 73 or fails to fix what’s broken.”
Act 73 is a product of last year’s legislative session, with its central tenet being the consolidation of the state’s 52 supervisory unions and 119 districts. The group assigned to present the legislature with a map of how best to accomplish that consolidation did not follow the law’s statutory language to reduce the number of supervisory unions. They dropped the consolidation plan altogether, contending that such consolidation would not achieve savings and was unduly unpopular statewide. It changed course and instead proposed a voluntary program for school districts to consolidate themselves and to set up “cooperative service areas” that could produce meaningful savings.
The governor has the upper hand with a message that’s easily understood and politically powerful. The state’s demographics are also in his favor. We continue to lose students, and roughly three-quarters of all homes are occupied by people who no longer have children in school. They care more about their expenses than spending more on schools. And they vote.
It’s also axiomatic that you can’t address the educational system’s needs without also addressing health care and housing. They are all part of the same circle of overlapping challenges that make any resolution problematic.
But the governor made it crystal clear that reforming our school system is the state’s most pressing concern. He will need to compromise to achieve that goal. And our educators will need to be advocates for a new system that not only works but is less expensive. They can’t remain on the sidelines. This is their moment.
At the session’s end, let’s hope we can look back and be hopeful.
by Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here