If the landmark education bill being advanced through the Senate were to become law the Enosburg-Richford school district would get an additional $5.3 million to spend.
Nice.
Except for this: The taxpayers in that district would see their property tax bills go up 32 percent to pay for it.
That’s a problem. No matter what else is included in the legislation. Only a third of the taxpayers in that district have children in school. If the school district thought it was essential to have another $5.3 million to spend they had that choice. They didn’t.
It gets worse. The Senate’s proposal to shift to a foundation formula makes the decision for them. If the bill became law taxpayers would not get to vote. The bill goes up 32 percent. An increase of varying percentages would be levied on every taxpayer in Franklin County, except for those living in the Maple Run Union School District.
For most of Franklin County that's a recipe for revolt.
Will it happen? Maybe, but most likely not. But perhaps it’s useful to consider one of the more extreme parts of the bill as a proxy for what ails the Senate bill overall and the differences between H.454 passed by the House and the Senate version of the same bill.
• Reduced to its simplest, the House bill makes a serious effort to address how much it costs to educate our students and proposes changes in governance to reduce spending. The Senate bill does not.
• The House bill sets up class size minimums. The Senate bill does not.
• The House bill sets up minimum size requirements for school districts. The Senate does not.
• The House bill sets up a Commission on the Future of Public Education, made up of legislators, school board members, business managers, and former school superintendents. The commission’s responsibility would be to set up the reduced number of state school districts. The Senate drops the commission and, in its place, would have the work performed by eight legislators, none of which have any educational experience. [Politics trumps experience.]
• The House bill would stop funding out-of-state private schools. The Senate bill does not.
• The House bill limits independent school tuition to those schools that have long served the role of public schools where none exist. The Senate’s bill allows taxpayer dollars to be spent on private schools 25 miles from our border.
• The House bill appoints two legislators to the State Board of Education. The Senate bill does not.
• The foundation formula is a part of both House and Senate bills, but there seems to be a mystery as to how the Senate arrived at its figures.
• The Senate bill pegs school spending at 2025 levels but allows for a small inflation index, not addressing the core issues pushing up the cost of education, such as health care premiums, and long ignored deferred maintenance costs.
As has been publicly acknowledged, the Senate version of the bill passed out of committee has almost no defenders. Many quoted say it stinks. The figures used are being doubted. Intent is being second-guessed. No one is happy with the bill. The primary defense is, as articulated by Franklin County State Senator Randy Brock, that any bill is better than no bill. If passed this week, at least the stage will be set for a conference committee with the House.
But why would the Senate opt to put up such a weak hand?
In a word: politics. The Democratic leadership is terrified of losing its majority in the next election. With its proposal, they can say they held the line on spending by capping costs at 2025 levels. And they can sidestep any of the hard work embraced by the House, including setting minimum sizes for classes and school districts and tightening up state spending for out-of-state tuition.
And we wonder why Vermont struggles so hard to solve its problems.
Gov. Phil Scott made the call when the session began. He identified the cost of education as the Legislature’s most critical task, and he presented a plan to help fix things. He also warned of not succumbing to the political waters of denial.
Since then, he's waited for the Legislature to do its work. With time running short and the legislative outline from both the House and Senate relatively clear, it's time for the governor to reinsert himself into the debate. Mr. Scott is the one with the political capital and if he truly wants to see a workable plan emerge that meets his expectations [and the state's needs] then he must step up now. He knows full well we cannot afford the school system we have, which is 40,000 students less than what we had a generation ago. He knows full well we can’t reduce costs to an acceptable level, and provide a competitive educational experience without reducing the number of schools, particularly within our middle and high schools. And he knows full well that the most difficult of these decisions - reducing the number of schools and the number of school districts can't be left to local school boards.
If the governor made that message crystal clear it would help push the debate toward the House’s direction in the expected conference committee, and it would lay bare the weakness of the Senate’s choice to choose political cover over the need to solve Vermont's problems.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here