The humiliation was unexpected and became too much. Last week House Speaker Mike Johnson told his Republican charges to withdraw from the field of battle. No more public events. No more town hall meetings with constituents. If the representatives were to be jeered by what was expected to be friendly audiences, they would go silent.
The town meetings were held across the country and the constituent responses were the same; people were angry with the Trump administration’s policies and wanted their reps to hear them.
But this is an administration that doesn’t countenance opposition. Those who support them are rewarded, those who do not are punished and ignored.
The same anger that prompted a Kansas senator to walk out of his own town meeting extends to Vermont. There is a growing call for Republican Gov. Phil Scott to hold his own town meeting to draw attention to the state’s widespread opposition to Mr. Trump.
That’s to be expected. Gov. Scott won his November election with 73 percent of the vote. Mr. Trump gathered a paltry 31 percent. Since there are far more registered Democrats than Republicans in Vermont, it’s a given that Mr. Scott is hearing from Democrats and Progressives who voted for him but are in solid opposition to Mr. Trump.
They want him to stand up in full-throated opposition to Mr. Trump. Every day. On every issue. The opportunities are endless. And it would make them feel better.
Mr. Scott prefers the softer touch. He called the president out when he falsely claimed that Ukraine began the war with Russia. But he sees little point in antagonizing when it’s not in the state’s best interests. In a press conference last week he said, “I don’t believe that creating more anxiety across the board and trying to answer questions we have no answers to would be in the best interest of Vermonters…”
The governor also said taking on the president at every turn would play into the president’s hands, meaning Mr. Trump would take delight in punishing Vermont should Mr. Scott want to enter the field of battle with any regularity.
In a Seven Days story, former Lt. Gov. David Zuckerman tried to score some political points by saying “The bottom line is there is a time and place to stand up on the right side of history, and if this isn’t it, I don’t know what is.”
We’re not quite sure who pays attention to Mr. Zuckerman these days, but there can’t be anyone in the state who doesn’t know that the governor didn’t vote for Mr. Trump in 2016 or 2024. There can’t be anyone who isn’t aware that he is opposed to the president’s style or his policies. But he’s smart enough to know that opposition for opposition’s sake is pointless. We’re a tiny state and the federal government constitutes a large percentage of our spending. Pick your battles.
As former Gov. Howard Dean said, “His job is to be the governor of Vermont, not to take a bite out of a crazy guy who happens to be president.”
Spot on.
It may soothe the soul to see the governor dress down the president for his brutish, non-sensical, and counterproductive policies. The satisfaction, however, wears thin when you’re ignored. It becomes less fun when the flow of federal dollars to places like UVM begins to slow to a trickle, and when federal programs dealing with the state’s health care reform efforts dry up.
As most Vermonters can attest, the governor has a full plate. He’s got an entire preK-12 educational system to improve and make more affordable. He’s got a healthcare system on the verge of collapse if not properly tended to. He has a state in desperate need of more housing and growth.
These are all issues that have a direct impact on everyday Vermonters. Mr. Scott’s first obligation is to address these issues and to resist the temptation to step into the gutter with Mr. Trump.
Does that mean Vermonters should not spill out into the streets in protest? No. To the contrary. Solidifying our beliefs from within keeps us focused on the midterm election in two short years.
That’s what frightens Mr. Johnson.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here