Gov. has chance to put health of Vt above a couple of bucks

Posted

The Vermont House last week joined the Senate in approving a bill that would ban flavored nicotine products and tobacco substitutes. The passage of the legislation has been a years-long campaign that has pitted the healthcare community against users of the products, the companies that produce them, and the commercial establishments that make money selling them. The bill will soon be on Gov. Phil Scott’s desk, and it’s anyone’s guess whether he will sign it, or veto it.

The arguments against the bill are an echo of times past. Adults should be able to do what they want. The products are not that bad for you. It is good for business and the state rakes in a lot of cash.

But there was a reason tobacco companies were forced to stop marketing their products, and there was a reason the industry was forced to pay $206 billion in health care damages to each state over the first 25 years of the tobacco settlement agreement. Their products kill people. 

They still do. Each year 1,000-plus Vermonters lose their lives to cancer caused by smoking. 

The thought behind today’s legislation is that we can lower the number of people who die each year by discouraging the use of flavored nicotine products that appeal to our youth. It’s an established fact - and patently obvious - that if fewer people use nicotine products and tobacco substitutes, then fewer people will end up smoking, and fewer people will die.

The lawmakers opposed to the ban are focusing primarily on the bill’s economic costs. It’s been estimated that the ban would cost the state between $7 million and $15 million in lost revenue. The governor has also expressed concern about the estimated loss.

That’s nuts.

Compare that $15 million in tax revenue to the $404 million it costs Vermont each year to treat those directly affected by smoking. Compare it to the $575 million each year in smoking-caused productivity losses. If the cost of smoking - writ large - is calculated on a per-household basis, it would cost each Vermont household $1,072.

How about trying to save that $7 million-$15 million by reducing the number of people getting sick from the products’ use?

That’s what the move to ban flavored nicotine products would do. It would reduce the number of young adults who would use the addictive nicotine products as a gateway to cigarettes and other tobacco-related uses.

And for those who are using the lost tax revenue as the reason to oppose the bill, do they really want to equate the importance of lost revenue to the loss of lives? To the cost of our health care system that needs to treat them?

Some lawmakers opposed are hanging their hats on an equity argument, mainly that the legislation is “targeted” against Black and LGBTQ+ users. Menthol cigarettes are disproportionately used by these two groups and one legislator, Rep. Saudia LaMont, D-Morristown, was quoted as saying: “It says that Black people and LGBTQ+ people are not intelligent enough to come up with their own decisions and articulate their own vices with autonomy.”

That makes no sense. Think about it. Would it be a better bill to carve out an exemption for black and LGBTQ+ people? Would it be better to pass a law that puts the health of the general public as our foremost objective, but, oh, by the way, our concern doesn’t extend to blacks or LGBTQ+ people, because they can fend for themselves?

That’s idiotic. It also ignores the fact that both communities had their own lobbyists who testified in favor of banning the menthol products.

The irony in all this is that the opposition’s core argument is economic. They don’t want to lose the $7 million-$15 million in tax revenue. They see the law as weakening commerce. Yet, it’s the continuation of the practice [use of nicotine products] that weakens the economy, that pushes up the cost of health care, that makes us less healthy,

Mr. Scott is a lifelong athlete. He champions the state’s healthcare community and speaks to the need to strengthen our preventative care efforts. He also recognizes that roughly 70 percent of Vermonters polled favor this ban, a level of support just as strong among Republicans as Democrats. Let’s trust the governor does the right thing - for the health of us all - and signs the bill into law.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here