Franklin County made it to Gov. Phil Scott’s budget address Monday. And not in a good way.
Mr. Scott was talking about crime and how he and the Legislature had made the mistake of being too lenient with legislation to “raise the age of criminal accountability” and “well intentioned goals” without recognizing the consequences.
The governor pointed to several examples, including ours: “…On at least four occasions, a woman in Franklin County was arrested for narcotic sales and released on conditions. So instead of being in jail, she continued selling crack and fentanyl. By the way, she was also involved in a homicide in Leicester, all because she wasn’t held accountable.”
Nice.
As the governor admitted, he signed the bill in question into law. He wanted to believe things would improve, that the laws would not end up making Vermont less safe. As he noted, “… conditions of release aren’t effective, which makes it harder to prevent people from harming their neighbors and communities, over and over and over.”
The governor asked the Legislature to rethink two laws, one being a 2018 law that made it more difficult for courts to hold alleged offenders in custody as they awaited their criminal trials, the other being the “Raise the Age” law that disallowed juveniles from being charged as adults.
Vermont was first in the nation with its “Raise the Age” law, and it seemed appropriate to separate young people from adult offenders. But since then, the overriding issue in Vermont is drug use and the concomitant issues of crime including shoplifting, vandalism, assault and theft. Drug dealers outside Vermont also saw their chance to use our law to their benefit. They began recruiting younger people to sell their drugs in Vermont since their couriers would not be prosecuted as adults. As the governor said, the law has made Vermont a “destination state” for major traffic traffickers.
If we were talking about pot, that would be a different discussion. We’re talking about highly addictive drugs and drugs much more deadly than anything we’ve experienced before. It’s the central reason Vermont continues to see a record number of deaths attributed to overdoses.
For Democrats and the leadership that gave rise to the laws in question it is a difficult issue. To relent to the governor’s request would be tantamount to retreat from their beliefs. Speaker of the House Jill Krowinski’s take on the governor’s speech was that it was “long on fear and short on hope” and that she didn’t think “sending kids to jail isn’t going to solve our problems. We need to make investments in our justice system to handle the backlog that we have.”
No one says sending juveniles to jail would solve all our problems. But discouraging drug cartels from using our youth to their advantage would be a major step in the right direction. That much should be obvious.
And Ms. Krowinski’s suggestion that we pile money into an underfunded judicial system, while defensible, is hardly anything that would produce timely results or that would encourage drug cartels to shift to another market. It would do nothing to restore the “hope” she says is missing from the governor’s approach.
It’s also an election year, and we can expect the debate on this issue to be front and center for legislators and Vermonters. It should be. We’ve lost the distinction of being the nation’s safest state. People won’t move here if they are concerned about their safety upon arrival. Nor will people stay.
The governor was big enough to say he made a mistake to sign the cited measures into law. It’s time for the Democrats to admit the same and move ahead.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here