Got a problem? Just ask the taxpayers

Posted

With the cost of gas rising, along with housing, food, utilities, and healthcare, it would seem axiomatic that Vermont’s legislators would want to be seen as being helpful, to be credited for reducing costs, not raising them. Yet, here we are, moments away from adjournment, watching as House Democrats debate the difference between their seven percent property tax increase and the Senate’s four percent proposal.

Vermonters must wonder whether the leadership in both Houses ever talks. Or whether the House leadership ever gets out of Montpelier to listen to the taxpayers.

It would be a short conversation.

Vermonters have swallowed hard to come up with the money needed to educate our students. They’ve watched their property tax bills explode, rising over 40 percent in the last five years. Asking them to choose between a four-percent increase and a seven-percent increase for next year is a no-brainer.

But that’s exactly what House Dems would like to see happen.

We get it. They believe next year’s increase will be even higher if they don’t save half the $105 million budget surplus for next year’s property tax bill. Even Gov. Phil Scott admits that using the entire budget surplus doesn’t solve the spending issue. But the bigger issue is the immediate impact on Vermonters whose pocketbooks have been tapped from all angles. The Senate’s Democratic leadership has also sided with Mr. Scott.

Easy choice. There is a little more than six months before November’s election. Any legislator who supports raising property taxes by seven percent [instead of four] will have a difficult time persuading taxpayers that they are acting in the public’s best interests.

Legislators supporting the seven percent proposal should also put themselves in the taxpayers’ position. When they say next year’s tax increase will be even higher and that using only half the surplus will soften the increase, they are also telling the taxpayer not to expect any relief anytime soon. They are saying, well, you’re going to get hit by a seven percent increase this year, and probably another tax increase of the same amount or more next year. Nothing we can do about it.

There’s no relief in that message. Zip.

It makes it sound as if we should just get used to it. Nothing is going to change. Ever.

That’s not a message taxpayers want to hear. It’s not a message that attracts families from beyond our borders. It’s not a message that keeps people here.

No one pretends the answers are simple. But we can’t be idle in our responses. We’ve witnessed a 30,000-student decline since the late 1990s. We have a multi-billion-dollar construction bill pending. We’ve seen a troubling decline in academics. And we sit on the top rung of the nation’s most expensive school system.

And the good news is?

The governor has already said he would veto the seven percent option. The Dems don’t have the votes to override him. The Senate agrees with the governor. So why are House Democrats wasting time and, in the process, dimming the hopes of taxpayers who are looking for relief and some progress?

Good question.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here