Give away $150M in fed matching funds? No way.

Posted

It’s the least sexy part of the state’s budget, but the part Vermonters expect to be handled without delay, without question, and without political bickering. It’s the transportation fund. To fix the potholes. To keep the roads clear and paved. To repair our weather-beaten bridges.

But we have a problem: We have a 21st-century transportation system largely funded by a 1920s model collection program - the gas tax at the pump. Our cars have become more efficient. The rise in electric vehicles continues. Thus, the transportation revenue continues to decline while the cost of construction has doubled since the beginning of the century.

This is all playing out center stage as the Legislature and Gov. Phil Scott figure out how to plug a $33 million hole. That’s the amount the state needs to match the federal funds Vermont needs to meet its transportation needs. Without the $33 million, we lose roughly $150 million in matching federal funds. 

That can’t be allowed to happen. Postponed transportation projects end up being vastly more expensive. Quickly. 

The issue for the Legislature has now been ranked alongside health care, housing, and education. 

Rep. Matt Walker, R-Swanton, and Republican chair of the House Committee on Transportation, was quoted in a Vermont Public story as saying, “The state has always had a policy, Republican or Democrat administration, to maximize all federal dollars…coming up with that match money is a bigger and bigger struggle.”

That’s true, but the state has a budget of roughly $6 billion, which means that $33 million is less than a percent of the total budget. It has already been suggested that $20 million of the $33 million gap could be met by paying for Vermont State Police services from the general fund rather than the transportation fund. Smart choice if the alternative is losing $150 million in federal matching funds.

Finding the remaining $13 million or so shouldn’t be a hard lift. Vermonters have every reason to believe the missing money will be found, considering the consequences if it’s not.

But that’s for next fiscal year. The bigger question is how we configure things so that the gap doesn’t expand the year after, and the year after that. 

It’s not all gloom. Beginning January 1, 2027, Vermont will collect a per-mile driven fee for owners of fully electric cars. It’s set to be the equivalent of people who pay for gas at the pump. That will help. But only a smidgen. All together that makes up a little less than a quarter of the transportation fund. The largest contributor to the fund is the purchase and use tax, the six percent tax collected when you buy a car in Vermont, which raises about 30 percent of the fund’s total. DMV fees add another 20 percent.

State economists project the decline in gas tax revenue will be about a percent each year for the next half decade. The efficiency of cars will continue to push down the total collected. And if the economy tanks and people buy fewer cars, it will decline even further. 

Altogether, it means we need to come up with different ideas as the transportation sector continues to evolve toward driverless cars, etc.  For example, the consideration of public-private partnerships to design, build, and operate the state’s infrastructure. Or, the consideration of how AI is being used to extend the life of our roads and bridges. Through artificial intelligence sensors and a “fix it before it breaks’ mentality, we can significantly reduce the cost of rebuilding something before it falls apart.

Then, there is the basic acceptance that we may have to pay a little more to meet the funding levels required to have the federal government pay half the cost of our transportation needs.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here