Get rid of cell phones in school, but focus on AI

Posted

By this time next year, Vermont schools will have in place a policy that prohibits students from using their cell phones or non-school-issued personal electronic devices from the time they arrive until the time they leave. The required direction is part of H.480, passed by the Legislature and signed into law by Gov. Phil Scott. 

The reasons are multiple. Cell phones in the classroom are an obvious distraction. They contribute to a student’s inability to concentrate. They are a critical part of the reason why rates of teen suicide and depression have mushroomed. Mr. Scott was quoted in last week’s story by Messenger Publisher Bridget Higdon, “The things our cell phones can do today are amazing; however, the one area they seem to be very good at is their ability to distract us from everything. Taking a break from our phones is probably a good policy for all of us to follow - and hopefully, find that healthy balance we could all use a little more of.”

That healthy balance also includes battling what the Surgeon General’s report on social media says includes “poor sleep, online harassment, poor body image, low self-esteem, and higher depressive symptom scores.”

The law is a good one. Cell phones will go down as one of the key inventions of our time. That doesn’t mean their incessant use is healthy. It isn’t. Particularly for our children.

But their multi-hour-a-day use is one problem; the much bigger challenge on the immediate horizon is how AI is changing the educational landscape. For parents [or teachers] not aware of AI and its vast potential, it’s worth a stroll through ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, Llama, or Copilot. It’s easier to say what AI chatbots can’t do than what they can. Want a 500-word summation of Shakespeare’s 20 best works? Done within the minute. Want an explanation of Trump’s “big beautiful bill?” Done. Want the math behind a quantum physics question? No worries. Want to trace the key philosophical thoughts of Aristotle, Kant, Plato, and Karl Marx and to see how one influenced the other? Just ask, you’ll have an answer almost immediately.

You might not be aware, but your children are. 

A Microsoft study in June reported that 93 percent of students across the nation [ages 16 and above] have used AI. That same study showed that 42 percent of students used it weekly for school, and 30 percent use it every single school day. In January, the Center for Democracy and Technology reported that 75 percent of all high school students used AI for their studies in the 2023-2024 school year. A July 2025 Quizlet report found that 89 percent of students ages 14-22 reported using AI for school work.

As any high school teacher will tell you, it’s increasingly difficult to tell when a student is doing the work themselves or asking a chatbot for a little high-quality help. Many teachers are requiring their students to do their homework in class, in long-hand, just in case.

In other words, parents will need to be more attentive to students’ practices than ever before. And the AI revolution is in its infancy. We can only speculate which professions will be most affected, or to what degree life as we know it will change. In Monday’s Washington Post, there was an editorial piece that gauged how AI would impact 700 professions. Thinking of being a translator? Don’t. The chances of the job being automated are sky high. Same with software developers. A power plant operator? Go for it. Good job security.

How about secondary school teachers? The study, done by the researchers at Anthropic, the AI company running Claude, shows that AI is “currently automating 23 percent of the teachers' job functions and augmenting 34 percent of them.”

That’s today. And, no question, there are benefits to the teaching profession being open to AI’s advantages. It could reduce teachers’ administrative burden. It could also generate tailored lesson plans for individual students and refine teaching strategies. It could foster better creativity and critical thinking skills. The list goes on and on. 

But to be successful would require the teaching profession [and its leaders] to be ahead of what’s about to become rather than behind. That’s why the conversation about students not being able to have their cell phones in school feels a bit like yesterday’s thinking. Of course, they should not be allowed in school, but how is the educational system preparing itself for the AI tsunami that is headed our way?

That’s the critical question facing Vermont. For a state that has seen its school-aged population drop and its test scores sink, figuring out how to use AI to our rural state’s advantage should be our highest priority. As we work to figure out how the education system can be made more affordable, let’s also consider how it can be made better.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here