It has begun. Interim president of Vermont State University Mike Smith this week sent an email to all his students saying the school had started the process of figuring out which of the school’s academic offerings would remain and which would be dropped. Mr. Smith also hinted at the obvious, which was the inevitability of layoffs should the school drop or consolidate degree programs.
The school has no politically acceptable alternative. It’s running a $20 million deficit and is operating with the understanding that it must cut five million dollars per-year for the next five years. The Legislature has already appropriated tens of millions of dollars to the Vermont State College system over and above its normal appropriation levels. It has been made clear that VSC can no longer expect similar increases.
Mr. Smith is doing what he must, expressing confidence there is a path forward for the university but stressing that to succeed will require significant change. The unions representing the faculty and staff have already responded to Mr. Smith’s efforts with a big thumbs down. The unions opposed the school’s prior efforts to pare back the schools’ libraries. They can be expected to oppose anything that results in teachers’ losing their jobs.
The unions have a point. They are the ones who, for the last three-plus years, have been forced to sit back and watch all this unfold, not knowing whether they would have jobs. It’s been a lot. Never in VSC’s history has there been so much change or uncertainty. It’s a reflection of the demographic changes in the state. Everyone is chasing fewer and fewer students.
The importance of Mr. Smith’s notice this week is that it pushes VSU where it needs to be pushed. The task is to downsize and still maintain its academic standing; not an easy dance.
Here, however, is the challenge. Mr. Smith’s last day in the job is a little over a month away. This week Vermont State Colleges Chancellor Sophie Zdatny also announced she would be stepping down from her position by year’s end. That’s a colossal change in leadership, and it comes at a time when the system is at its weakest. It puts in question the likelihood of anything proposed now being in place a year from now.
That is not a comforting picture for anyone - the faculty, staff, or students. VSU saw a 20 percent decline in its student count this year [that does not include the Community College of Vermont, which has seen an increase and is doing well fiscally.] If this uncertainty isn’t corrected, VSU may see a further decline. It’s a battle of perception. Students and their parents want to be part of a system showing strength, not weakness. They have choices, and they will choose according to what is to their advantage.
This puts VSC’s Board of Trustees in a inescapable position. The board must choose wisely to fill Mr. Smith’s and Ms. Zdatny’s positions. And it must do far more than it has in the past in terms of defending its choices and then staying the course. It would seem imperative, and obvious, that those selected to fill the two open positions need to know the trustees have their backs, that when the ride becomes bumpy - and it will - that the trustees don’t go silent.
This support/leadership is crucial. Anyone who accepts either job offer is taking a chance on their future career path. They have to know and to accept Mr. Smith’s plan. They have to believe in its potential for success, before they sign on. They have to know they won’t be one-person shows.
Paradoxically, it may be important to explain upfront just how extensive the cuts will need to be, and where the cuts will be made. In other words, let’s get to the bottom as fast as we can get there, rather than slug through another three of four years, prolonging the uncertainty, and undermining any faith that the VSC system can once again be made robust. That is the only fair thing for the staff and faculty, and the only way that future students can best gauge the wisdom of their choices.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here