Forgive the jaundiced eye, but....

Posted

Another pro-housing advocacy group has stepped on the Vermont stage saying if Vermont does not get its act together the middle class will be crowded out and all that will remain is a state affordable to the “rich and famous.” 

The group, headed by former Burlington Mayor Miro Weinberger, is called Let’s Build Homes and it’s attracting support from all those one would expect - other housing groups, non-profits, business leaders, developers and politicians. As for the importance of the cause, it’s being termed “existential” meaning all other things of value will suffer if it’s not successfully addressed.

But most observers will be little moved by yet another group of well-heeled Vermonters shouting about the state’s need to add housing to its depleted stock. This is old news. The Legislature responded to these same shouts of desperation last session when it passed Act 181 which included tweaks to Act 250, the state’s land use planning law.

The problem with the new law is that it was deeply flawed, yet few among this week’s new advocacy group said anything about it. So what changed? November’s election. The new political balance in the Legislature makes it easier to call into question policies that are not effective, or less effective than they should be. That's the power of bipartisanship, or something closer to it than we've had.

The intent of Let’s Build Homes is to be the state's advocacy group on the issue. But if it’s to be effective it will need the political and financial muscle to take on and change Vermont’s anti-growth culture. Otherwise, it will quickly fade and be little more than a line on a political resume. 

The story pitch is not just about need, it’s about how it can be accomplished and how the results could trump the downsides. We know we need more homes. We also know - or should - that our housing needs can’t be met house-by-house, town-by-town. That’s not affordable. Nor does it ever get us to the level of housing construction that we need. We know we will need a new financing mechanism - like the suggested version of a Tax Increment Financing [TIF] plan. [We’ve been writing about this for years.] We also know that our housing needs can’t be split into a goal equally divided between each of the state’s 247 incorporated cities and towns. There are good places to build, and poor ones.

If Let’s Build Homes is to be successful, it has to recognize that its mission is to sell a message, to find the opposition and expose its weaknesses, to explain to the average Vermonter how an adequate supply of housing protects their interests and their way of life. The objective is to take the nastiness out of growth, to show how it adds, not subtracts, from a life of moderate prosperity.

Non-profit advocacy groups are a dime a dozen in Vermont. They typically fade into the background because they get chewed up by other non-profits with similar objectives, overlapping supporters, and long shelf lives. It’s easy to understand why the cynics would view Let’s Build Homes with the same jaundiced eye.

We hope otherwise for Let’s Build Homes. The cause is pivotal to Vermont, its economy, and its people. There is also the distinct advantage of timing. November’s election reduced the friction between Vermont’s political parties. A sense of humbleness has swept the state’s Democrats and, for at least the moment, there seems to be an understanding that Vermonters are calling a halt to anything that doesn’t correct a wrong. People want things to work. 

There is no better example of something that doesn’t work than the policies that make it difficult to build the homes we need and the age-old anti-growth culture that threatens to make Vermont a haven for the well-to-do and unaffordable for working-class Vermonters. That is a cruel juxtaposition of circumstances going back to the early 1970s when Gov. Dean Davis sought to thread the needle between the benefits of growth and the need to protect the environment.

Mr. Davis sought balance, something missing in today’s Vermont. To get it back will require a full-throated response and one that is sustainable. Let’s hope that Let’s Build Homes accepts the challenge and has the courage to break a couple of eggs along the way.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here