With chaos coming from all sides and with the uncertainty about the nation’s direction growing by the minute it’s hard to know how to respond. We also don’t know what the future holds, short or long-term.
Closer to home, there is less ambiguity. Those who lead us in Vermont have not gone off the rails. We aren’t “disappearing” people. We aren’t slashing payrolls. And we generally follow the rule of law.
Still, our hard cold realities have a bite of their own, perhaps none as troubling as the next round of health care premiums, something that, directly or indirectly, affects us all. As we have been warned by the Green Mountain Care Board [GMCB], for 2025 we can expect our healthcare premiums to increase anywhere from 15 percent to 30 percent. In actual dollars that translates to a monthly premium of $1277 for the “average lowest-cost silver premium.”
If this monstrous cost increase were an aberration that would be one thing. It isn’t. Look at the chart below.
There is everyone else, and then us. The line that defines the national average starts out in 2018 at around $475 per month. Vermont is right there with the national average. Then, the big divergence begins. In 2022, the national average declined to around $450 a month. Vermont's soars to $725. In 2024, the national average inches up to what it was in 2018, meanwhile Vermont’s number hits around $950, more than double the national average. In 2025 the national average rises, hitting $500 a month, the highest in seven years. But Vermont jumps a whopping $327 per month, driving our monthly premium costs to $1,277.
So what does this look like to the representative family of four in Vermont? As the second chart shows*, in 2025 the annual premium for BCBSVT is about $48,000.
Who can afford that?
The GMCB, the state’s health care system regulator, will receive the rate requests from BCBSVT and MVP next month. There is not a lot of flexibility in what the board can offer. BCBSVT had to borrow $30 million from its parent company in Michigan last year just to stay in business. Their operating cash is minimal. If BCBSVT were forced to leave Vermont, the burden would fall to MVP, but MVP can’t handle BCBSVT’s volume, raising the real potential that it would exit Vermont as well.
Then what? 70,000 Vermonters lose their health insurance.
The answer? BCBSVT can’t be allowed to fail. Everything falls apart if it does. [It's terrifying that we are even having this discussion. It’s a circumstance that keeps GMCB’s five members up at night.]
The obvious approach is to wring the necessary money out of Vermont’s healthcare system. But that’s also a selective process. Six of the state’s hospitals are operating in the red. Only one, UVMMC, has a sizable operating margin.
As the Oliver-Wyman study of the state’s health care system last year warned, what we have doesn’t work. We can’t have 14 hospitals with a full set of services in today’s world and not expect the price increases we are experiencing.
The Legislature is currently pushing legislation that would increase the authority of the GMCB in the oversight of pricing practices of our hospitals and their governance structures. As GMCB chair Owen Foster testified, the legislation is not about punishing hospitals it’s about “creating safety values” so that “systemic failures” can be avoided. It’s important that the legislation be passed and signed into law by the governor. In fact, it’s crucial. It’s hard to see how our healthcare system properly functions without it.
That said, it’s a heavy lift.
We have already seen the response from communities whose hospitals were among those advised to significantly change their operations. They wanted nothing to do with it. They wanted their hospitals to remain as is. Fully functioning. No changes.
We watched the high-stakes battle unfold between UVM Health Network and GMCB over differences in budget requests and how the hospital operates. UVM Health Network has over $1.3 billion in reserves. Obviously, UVM will have a key role in shaping Vermont’s healthcare system’s future.
What is apparent is that we have allowed the healthcare crisis to simmer beyond the boiling point. That’s unfortunate. Much has been placed at risk because we have operated in our own little silos with little attention, or advocacy, paid to the health of our overall healthcare system. That inattention has created an imbalance between providers, the state’s regulator, and the Vermonters who pay the bills.
This isn’t a Vermont problem. It can’t be explained away by our lousy demographics, there are other states that are older and have lower per capita incomes than Vermont. Yet, we still pay far more than anyone else for our health care. We have to be able to deal with this, but to do so will require getting beyond the politics of self-interest, or self-preservation. We have allowed something that should have been controllable to spawn into something that threatens us at a fundamental level - our health and how we are cared for.
So, yes, it’s more sane here than in the nation’s capital. But that’s cold comfort when we are staring at healthcare prices that are not affordable and a system on the brink of collapse. We need to own it. The press in Vermont needs to write about it. We’re better than this.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here