First it was our hospitals, now it's our schools?

Posted

Vermont could spend $400 million to $460 million less than it currently spends on its schools and see a “substantial” improvement in student outcomes if it followed the guidance offered by third-party consultants in a report commissioned by the Vermont Legislature.

The report, researched and written by Picus Ogden & Associates, is an update to a similar report by the same experts in 2016. The intent of this year’s report - released in mid-September - was to speak to the need to reduce costs and to produce “high-performance” schools.

The timing of the report is spectacular. Vermonters are still exercised over this year’s 14 percent increase in property taxes [which funds our schools]. To cut spending by $460 million would be a 27 percent reduction in what we spend for our schools today. To cut spending by that much and, at the same time, substantially improve academic outcomes for our students?

Sign us up, right?

Except getting from where we are to where the consultants recommend, would require Vermont to embrace a massive consolidation effort. The consultants’ “evidence-based” model shows that the ideal size of an elementary school is between 400 - 500 students and a secondary school should have between 500 - 1,000 students. School districts should have roughly 3,900 students.

Schools that size can handle larger classes, which increases the number of students per teacher, which reduces costs. It allows schools to better target students’ needs. This level of efficiency is what would reduce our per pupil spending from $16,900 to between $12,300 and $12,900.

The study is useful in that it shows we can do better. It’s always important to be reminded that the best path forward requires change, transparency, and political leadership.

Still, the report is the second within the space of a month that speaks directly to Vermont’s culture and the struggle with our troubling demographics. The first was the Oliver Wyman consultancy report that detailed the peril of the current status of our hospitals: All are in jeopardy and those in our more rural environs could face bankruptcy if their operations are not reconfigured.

In sum, the reports conclude that our hospitals and schools are unduly expensive to run as configured, which, over time, puts the quality of services at risk. As our workforce ages and the number of students continues to decline the challenges to both systems will accelerate.

But addressing it is almost beyond our reach politically. Who among us is willing to say our small schools need to be consolidated? Who is willing to say some of our hospitals need to find different uses for their buildings? Which communities are willing to sacrifice what they have for what consultants say is a better and less costly system for education and healthcare?

It’s not going to happen. Not in the current political environment. Look at how the four communities have reacted to recommendations that their hospitals be closed or radically changed. Remember the antipathy to Act 46 which encouraged school districts to unify? Is there a community in Vermont that would embrace the need to close its school? 

No. It’s a bit like the Legislature’s current effort to address the need to consider regional government. The advantages could be pivotal for many communities, but it’s nothing that will happen anytime soon, if ever because it might intrude on the authority of our town-based governance model.

But here is a staggering statistic that should prompt us to begin the conversations: In 2000 there were 27 Americans above the age of 65 for every 100 Americans of working age. In 2020, that number had jumped to 39. By 2040 it will have increased to 54. Vermont’s numbers are slightly higher. That has enormous implications for both our healthcare system and our schools.

For a state whose identity is tied to its small-town culture and whose political leadership is limited by a two-year election cycle, it will take a groundswell in changed expectations to chart our path forward.

What we should acknowledge is that not doing anything will cost us far more later.

By Emerson Lynn 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here