Among President-elect Donalf Trump’s many targets is the alleged “censorship cartel” that pits social media firms against conservatives. His chosen regulators of the Federal Communications Commission and the Federal Trade Commission have already begun the work to dismantle any regulatory provisions that encourage social media platforms to remove content they deem offensive.
This should surprise no one. Mr. Trump is the largest shareholder of his Truth Social media company which is worth billions. Elon Musk is the world’s richest man and owner of X [formerly Twitter]. Both profit in an environment that is largely unregulated. Both profit from personal platforms that allow them to direct the national conversation as they wish.
Mr. Musk has taken the issue a step further saying the “censorship and advertising boycott cartel must end now!” Of course. That’s how he makes money.
Mr. Trump and Mr. Musk are not alone. Most big tech companies feel similarly. They’d prefer to be spared the expense and responsibility of deciding what speech is acceptable and which is not.
To an extent, we all should be. If Mr. Trump is making his move because he feels conservatives are unfairly censored by other social media companies [which is ridiculous, take a look at the traffic numbers] then can we expect the next president to tilt things to his or her advantage?
The problem is that political speech is being conflated with issues concerning things like content unsuitable for children, hate speech, fake news, or anything threatening the stability of our democratic values.
Most Americans have little trust in the willingness of social media companies to police themselves. For good reason. Most of the companies concerned - Mr. Musk’s included - have become less transparent about their practices and made access to their algorithms so expensive that most independent organizations can’t afford to check the companies’ practices.
The common denominator claim by tech companies is that the First Amendment protects them at any and all levels, but that new levels of technological innovation will adequately address today’s challenges. Just relax.
Right.
That might be closer to the truth if the landscape were more competitive. But it isn’t. The companies in place - Google, X, Meta, etc. - intend to do all within their power to keep what they have and to grow.
There are few things more important than the process by which we talk to one another. There are few things more important than being able to trust the information these platforms provide. And there are few things more important than having rules that support the need for the public’s safety, the nation’s democratic values, and a general sense of decency.
What gets us there is anyone’s guess, but as we move into the new year, few things are more important.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here