Expand Act 250 to 90 percent of Vt? That helps us build new homes?

Posted

When Act 127 was signed into law no one knew the mess it would create. The law was based on the need to make things more equal between schools that had “expensive to educate” students and schools that didn’t. It was a feel-good equity issue. No attention was paid to what the law would cost or how schools would react. Legislators this week repealed the law.

Having been burned once, you would think the Legislature would be wiser. Particularly on issues central to the state’s well-being.

You would be wrong.

The Legislature has before it H.687, which addresses the state’s housing crisis. If the current direction of the legislation continues, not only will the housing crisis remain, it will worsen. Gov. Phil Scott is correct when he says it would be an “economic disaster.”

Last year, when the “working group” discussions began, there was some hope that environmentalists, developers, and the public would find a path forward. Together. A lack of housing is Vermont's most pressing issue, something to which even environmentalists admit. The working group pushed forward, negotiating differences, and acknowledging the need for transparency and the inclusion of Vermont's communities.

But when the session began, legislators became prescriptive, and the public's role faded into the background. Legislators "jumped the shark" a bit with proposals far beyond what was originally thought would be included in the legislation.

The proposed legislation, for example, would extend Act 250’s reach from 15 percent of the state’s land to 90 percent. It would cover the state’s river corridors. It would include significant wetlands. It would include all prime agriculture soil, land above 2000 feet in elevation, and any land with steep slopes and “shallow depth to bedrock.”

That is an enormous overreach. Prime ag soils by themselves are roughly 276,000 acres. River corridors would include 209,000 acres [and 12,000 buildings.]

The regulatory apparatus required is enormous and at many levels duplicative. Little to nothing has been discussed about the legislation's cost, and little to no discussion has been devoted to how the legislation would meet the state’s critical need to expand its housing supply.

What the bill does is take the existing regulatory authority and expand it. Many-fold. The proposed legislation does little to make it easier or cheaper for developers to build. But should a developer want to build, you can rest assured the proposed expansion of the regulatory system would make it crystal clear where that development will not happen.

In other words, legislators have convinced themselves that Vermont is where everyone wants to live, which is not okay, and that barriers need to be put in place to control future growth and minimize the impact.

Hence, the legislation would make it next to impossible to build in a river corridor. It is why housing divisions greater than four homes would be under Act 250’s control. And even though the state’s definition of forested land has barely changed in 40 years, Act 250 would have expanded powers to make sure it never does.

[We specialize in saying what you can't do, just not in what you can.]

This is not a bill that will set Vermont on a worthwhile course to deal with its housing crisis. Not if the goal is to build enough new homes to make a difference. The legislation does nothing to help developers build homes at scale, which is the only means by which housing can be built that is affordable. The current estimate is that the state is about 40,000 homes short of its needs. We will never get close to bridging the gap if we can only build homes a handful at a time, homes that will be beyond the financial reach of the average Vermonter.

If Act 250 was the only environmental tool in Vermont’s kit, and if housing was built in an unregulated, haphazard fashion that would be one thing. But that’s not the case. Every region of the state has a strong regulatory presence when it comes to the environment. Land use planning is at the core of what happens in all our counties. The legislation being considered would expand that regulatory strength/reach further than anything we have experienced.

If that’s the intent of our legislators, fine.

Just don’t call it legislation to expand housing.

And don’t call it affordable. Failing to address the state’s housing crisis will be one of the most expensive choices the Legislature makes. [Sound familiar?]

Protecting the environment is important. We’ve pretty much got that down to a fine art. But people also need to be able to live here. That is where we stumble. It is crucial the public not be misled into thinking that our housing needs are about to be eased. They are not. Not with the legislation under consideration.

We were a year late in figuring out the mess that would be caused by Act 127. Let us not repeat the failure with this housing bill.

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here