Ed reform: Slow down, do it right, build trust

Posted

The purpose of Act 73 was to assign a task force to figure out a way to turn Vermont’s 119 school districts into something more efficient, less costly, and something that would improve our school system’s sagging academics. The task force was to create a map showing which school district belonged where, to whom they were accountable, and for what reasons. The assigned group would need to reach out to each district - the schools’ staff, administrators, board members, and the general public - to ask their thoughts.

[And on the seventh day, they could rest.]

The map is due December 1. The Legislature begins its review in early January.

Good luck with that.

This all began with Gov. Phil Scott, who saw Vermont’s educational system as broken, a system that was prohibitively expensive and underperforming. He was frustrated. The property taxes needed to fund our schools were making the state a tough place to live, along with housing that’s not affordable, and health care premiums that are the nation’s highest.

He’s not wrong.

But expecting an assigned task force - named by the governor and Legislature -  to draw up a map in a way that would resolve all issues has turned out to be a Sisyphean task. As predicted. Every move uncovers another complication, another division, raising the question, is more harm than good being done?

Which gets us to the proposal offered last Monday. A majority of the 11-member redistricting task force voted to support a proposal that would “incentivize voluntary mergers” of the state’s school districts. Only three members voted to oppose it. 

It’s a given that Mr. Scott is less than thrilled with the proposal. He’s advocated a massive push to consolidate the state’s school system into five regional districts. The idea of any proposal being voluntary is a non-starter. It’s an easy thing for the governor to oppose. He can criticize the group for failing to act, for missing the opportunity to cut costs. He has the political strength to do so, and he might be so inclined, particularly if he decides to run for a sixth term. We’ll see.

The concern about the task force’s early redistricting efforts was summarized by Jay Badams, a retired superintendent and member of the task force, who said, “We’re speculating in thinking that large-scale district consolidation is going to somehow save money. The research that we’ve consulted indicates, at best, that it might and it might not. To put the system through that much radical change for the possibility that there might be savings sure seems like a lot to ask for our communities.”

Instead, the approved proposal is a combination of two plans considered earlier. One examined redistricting around Vermont’s high schools, the other was setting up a board of cooperative educational services, which is used in other rural states and intended to help bordering school districts collaborate on services, which, if you think about it, is a precursor to potential consolidation.

It’s a 170-page proposal and one that goes into great detail. It’s set up as a 10-year plan that designs a process that sets up ways to succeed without destroying what works. It’s also a plan to build the trust essential to making future changes, something that today does not exist. It steps around the inevitable chaos that will come about if we begin by knocking all the players off the chessboard, which is what we’ve done in prior reform efforts. It gives our educational system the time to set up a return-on-investment process that helps schools understand what works best and then move accordingly. 

The proposal shows one example after another as to how it could be beneficial to the end goal, which is to reduce the cost of our educational system and to make it better. But the proposal also shows the folly of valuing speed over competency. Politically, that’s tough to swallow. Everyone wants it done yesterday. They want the money in their pockets. Today. After all, what can be simpler than just cutting?

But that’s a false economy. And a quicker way to the bottom. The fastest and best way to a goal is through a process that all parties can trust and understand. The governor needs to see the wisdom of this approach and be its champion. 

By Emerson Lynn

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here