“It sounds like regardless of what bill we vote on, we lose. We put the House bill up, we lose. We put the Senate bill up, we lose,” said Sen. Ginny Lyons, D-Chittenden Southeast.
The bill she was referring to is the education reform bill, H.454, legislation Gov. Phil Scott says is the session’s most important. The governor has made it clear he will keep legislators in Montpelier until they deliver something he can sign into law.
Let’s hope.
But Ms. Lyons’ lament is understandable. Her fellow colleague from Addison County, State Senator Ruth Hardy, explained her frustration in a single word. She called the Senate’s work on the bill “infuriating.” She’s a Democrat calling out members of her own party who control the place.
She’s right. The legislation pushed out by the Senate Education Committee was a political mishmash that missed the point on every front. Any momentum toward resolution before adjournment was not only arrested but made far more difficult than necessary.
But to Ms. Lyons’ point, if the Legislature bends to the governor’s will, and reports out legislation he can support, the blowback won’t disappear. Legislation of this significance can’t be written to please all parties. The problem has been allowed to fester too long to be solved by anodyne proposals.
An education reform bill, with the overriding intent to lower the cost of funding our schools, can’t get us from here to there without making some very difficult decisions. And difficult decisions make for unhappy constituents.
We have too many schools for the 40,000 fewer students we are educating. Some need to be closed or repurposed. The people in those communities will fight any attempt to do so and leaving it up to local school boards is a non-starter. Hence, the House’s version of the bill which sets up class size minimums and consolidates the number of Vermont’s school districts.
When the inner workings of the Senate’s bill became a bit clearer and people began to look at the new foundation formula and how it would affect different communities, the questions took a harder turn. How, in the example of taxpayers in Enosburg and Richford, can the state give the school district $5.3 million bucks more than they get now, yet the taxpayers in that district will see their property taxes skyrocket by 32 percent? That’s not an isolated example. It would happen in many communities from one end of the state to the other. And, by the way, the taxpayers in those districts have no options. They don’t get to vote.
So, in the case of Franklin County, which ranks just above the average in per household income, all our school districts [except for Maple Run] would get a bit more money, and the taxpayers of those same districts would see their property taxes jump. And they have no say in the matter.
Think people might squawk?
Just a bit.
There have been three responses to the governance bills being considered: first, is to continue the typical legislative process, which is to get the bills to a conference committee, sort out the differences, and then send the result to the governor for consideration; second, set up a summer study committee and postpone consideration of a bill until next year; third, extend the session, dispense with the session’s regular business, and then dedicate the time and effort necessary to report out legislation that can be defended.
The non-starter is postponing consideration of the legislation until next year. That’s an election year, which would make the bill more political than it currently is. The odds of nothing happening would multiply.
As sympathetic as we are to the fact that legislators work for peanuts and have other lives, it’s still their responsibility to get the work done. The governor is right to hold firm, saying no one goes home until he has his education reform bill. [Something legislators should want as well.]
The Senate’s poor work made the process more complicated, but that can’t be used as a reason to give up. To the contrary, perhaps the energy from Ms. Hardy’s anger [also felt by many of her peers] can be used to get the Senate back on track.
It’s understood any outcome will have its vocal detractors. That’s because we’ve kicked the can down the road for so long, refusing to do anything productive, that we are left with unavoidable options that bring with them some pain.
Delay things a year, the pain will increase. That should be incentive enough to stay the course. Get it done.
By Emerson Lynn
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here